Effects of Structured Support from Leader on Employee Satisfaction, Intention to Quit and Store Performance: Experimental Evidence from Grocery Stores
How to cite
Haeckl, Simone; Rege, Mari; Shaikh, Hammad.
2023. "Effects of Structured Support from Leader on Employee Satisfaction, Intention to Quit and Store Performance: Experimental Evidence from Grocery Stores." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010967.
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10967-1.1
Download:
BibTeX
·
RIS— for reference managers without a browser
translator. Zotero and most
others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
We have developed a web application aiming to increase leaders' supportive leadership behaviors. We run a field experiment in a supermarket chain to test whether structured support from leader increase employee motivation, reduce turnover and improve store performance.
Experimental design
Update after pilot but prior to implementation: removed engagement as an outcome variable and reduced the number of selected employees to two instead of three
We conduct a field experiment in a large grocery store chain in Norway to examine the effects of structured support from leaders on employees’ satisfaction and, subsequently, core KPIs of the stores. In the experiment, leaders will work with a leadership training app for 7-weeks. In addition, the leaders are encouraged to target two employees they work with closely while using the app. The content and features of the app differ by treatment arms.
Design details
Randomization method
Stratified randomization blocked on the contributions margin per month, Intention to quit at store level, and the share of satisfied customers, all median split based on baseline data. In addition, we have generated a block including only two stores in which the targeted employees have a 0% fulltime employment position. The fact that the position is set to 0% is likely an error in the data, but we expect that these employees might be different from those with a fixed positive employment rate. We randomized using the stratarand command in STATA on the resulting 9 strata. In the extended trial, we will also block on corporation (4-5 different corporations) and might not need to have a block for the 0% fulltime employment position. In the extended trial, we will also block on corporation (4-5 different corporations) and might not need to have a block for the 0% fulltime employment position.
Update on extended trial randomization after pilot but prior to implementation:
In the extended trial, we use stratified randomization blocked on corporation, Intention to quit at store level and for large corporations the contributions margin per month based on baseline data. For small corporations (less than 10 stores) we stratify using a median split on intention to quit. For medium corporations (more than 10 but less than 20 stores) we use intention to quit terciles, for large corporations (more than 20 stores) we use intention to quit terciles and median split on the contributions margin to generate strata. We randomized using the stratarand command in STATA on the resulting 31 strata.
Randomization unit
store
Clusters
First trial: 42.
Extension:If the trial goes well, we hope to expand the number of participating stores to 150. If we do not have to make major changes after the first trial, we will stack the data of both trials.
Update Extension: We were able to recruit 169 stores. Due to poor take-up in the first trial, we do not intend to stack the data.
Observations
First trial: 42 stores.
For each store, we observe at least the manager, the assistant manager, and 2 two additional employees.
For individual-level employee outcomes, this gives us a sample of 3*42=126.
For store-level outcomes, we have 42 observations.
Extension: 150 stores.
For each store, we observe at least the manager, the assistant manager, and 2 two additional employees.
For individual-level employee outcomes, this gives us a sample of 3*150=450.
For store-level outcomes, we have 150 observations.
Update Extension:169 stores.
For each store, we observe at least the manager, the assistant manager, and one additional employee.
For individual-level employee outcomes, this gives us a sample of 2*169=338.
For store-level outcomes, we have 169 observations.
Arms
Observations will be split equally between treatment and control. For the first trial, this means 21 stores in treatment and 21 stores in control, or 63 employees in treatment and 63 employees in control. For the extension, this means 75 stores in treatment and 75 stores in control, or 225 employees in treatment and 225 employees in control.
Update extension: We plan to have 85 stores in treatment and 84 stores in control, or 170 employees in treatment and 168 in control.
Primary outcomes
Update after pilot but prior to implementation: removed engagement as pilot showed little variation in this variable, updated dates
Primary outcomes :
Employee level outcomes:
Short term:
intention to quit, work satisfaction
Long term:
employee turnover
Store-level outcomes:
Index on store performance both Short-term (October-November) and Long-term (December-April)
Secondary outcomes
leader’s need support
frequency of leader-employee meetings
leader mindset
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.