Leadership and Team Productivity

How to cite

Shaikh, Hammad; Haeckl, Simone. 2023. "Leadership and Team Productivity." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010956. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10956-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hammad Shaikh* , Simone Haeckl

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010956
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10956-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-02-13 – 2023-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10956

Abstract

Economic output in most industries is the result of many individuals working together in a team. The team environment shares features present in a public good in that the team members are working towards a common goal and are sharing the rewards that result from the finalized output. Such an environment can promote incentives for free-riding, resulting in inefficient allocation of effort across team members,
diminishing the teams productivity. This paper examines the effects of having a leader in increasing the teams’ productivity. To do so, we first gather data on business school students who are randomly assigned into groups and work in high-stakes team projects as a part of their course work. We randomly encourage half of the teams to select a team leader that will be responsible for managing the team project. We then evaluate the effects of having a team leader on various outcomes such as the teams’ project grade and the self-reported quality of team meetings.

Intervention

We provide students in the treatment group with a Microsoft Excel sheet planner to organize their meeting. It prompts students to select a team leader who will help guide the meetings for the remainder of the course. Additionally, the Excel planner also prompts students to enter the meeting attendees, purpose of meeting, list of items completed since last meeting, list of next steps, and write a brief summary of the meeting. The control group is also given such a Microsoft excel sheet planner, but the ``Team Leader" row is omitted. We randomly assign half of the students into treatment group. Additionally, the leaders within the treatment group will also be prompted by email to participate in an online activity which will help teach them leadership skills, if take-up of the excel sheets is sufficiently high. The online activity will present the leader with information relating to division of tasks across team members, managing meetings, and setting effective goals.

Experimental design

The study takes place in a master's level research methods course for business students. The business students have one of the following specializations: Economics, Leadership, Innovation, Finance, or Marketing. The main assessment in this course is a research paper, weighted as 100% of their course grade. After receiving a few lectures on relevant research methods (e.g., multiple regression), students are randomly assigned into teams with 4 students each within their specializations. Then for each specialization, we randomize half of the teams to the treatment group. The treated teams receive an Microsoft Excel planner to manager their meeting which prompts them to set a team leader. The control group also receives the Microsoft Excel planner, but are not prompted to select a team leader. If there is sufficiently high utilizing of the Microsoft Excel sheets, we also plan to follow-up with the team leaders in the treated group and request them to participate in online modules designed to improve their leadership competency.

Design details

Randomization method
We carry out a randomization in Stata to assign teams to either the treatment or control group in a way so that we have balance in the number of treated and control teams within each field of study (Economics, Leadership, Innovation, Finance, and Marketing). That is we use field of study as a block and perform a complete randomization within each block.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is a team of students
Clusters
We are carrying out a pilot study without around 20 student teams.
Observations
Each team has around 4 students, so 20*4 = around 80 students.
Arms
We are planning to have 10 student teams in control (40 students) and 10 student teams in treatment (40 students).
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes are the teams' performance on the research paper, and the quality of teamwork as measured by a survey index.
Secondary outcomes
Secondary outcome is a binary variable for whether a team member feels that all team members worked sufficiently hard towards the project. We also plan to follow the students over time and collect data on whether they complete their degree, years spent until completion, and grades in subsequent courses.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords