The effects of known source and account labelling on the acceptability of saving by wives in Zambia

How to cite

BARR, ABIGAIL; DEKKER, MARLEEN. 2023. "The effects of known source and account labelling on the acceptability of saving by wives in Zambia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010949. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10949-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

ABIGAIL BARR* , MARLEEN DEKKER

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010949
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10949-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-02-15 – 2023-02-19
Countries
Zambia (Luapula Province)
JEL codes
C93, D14, J12, Z13
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10949

Abstract

The primary aim of this study is to establish whether, in rural Zambia, a wife saving in secret from her husband is more socially acceptable and less likely to be viewed as justifiable grounds for her being beaten by her husband if (1) the source of the money being saved is known to be her business and (2) the money is being saved into an account that is explicitly linked to her business. To investigate these issues, we will conduct a survey experiment involving 180 participants, 90 females, 90 males, who are members of savings groups in Luapula Province, Zambia.
To isolate specific ceteris paribus effects and provide context for our findings, we will also investigate the social acceptability of husbands saving in secret from their wives under the same set of scenarios and both wives and husbands saving and telling their spouses about the savings under the same set of scenarios.

Intervention

This is a survey experiment. The participants will be presented with vignettes in which a wife or husband is deciding to save and will be asked to evaluate the wife's or husband's decision. The following aspects of these vignettes will be exogenously varied: phrases about the origin of the money being saved and the nature of the account it is being saved into; whether the saver is a wife or husband; and whether the saver does or does not tell her/his spouse about the savings.

The participants will also be asked how justifiable it is for a husband to beat his wife having discovered that she has been saving in secret and, in these questions too, phrases about the nature of the account that is being saved into will be exogenously varied.

Experimental design

The participants will be members of savings groups in villages in Luapula Province, Zambia. The aim is to engage 180 participants, 90 male, 90 female, in the survey.

The survey will be conducted via one-to-one interviews by 7 trained field researchers, 3 female, 4 male.

The survey will be conducted in mid-February 2023.

Design details

Randomization method
Two lists have been drawn up, one for male participants, one for female participants. In each list, survey instrument variants and field researchers have been assigned to participant IDs in a way that assures balance across all relevant dimensions, including the location of a participant in the interview order. In the field, participant IDs will be assigned on a first-come-first-served basis.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization for the Set A vs SET B vs Set C variants is the participant. Each participant will make four evaluations and, across these four, tell vs don't-tell and saver-a-wife vs saver-a-husband are randomized. In the analysis, an observation will be an evaluation or a within-participant difference between two evaluations and these will be clustered by participant.
Clusters
180 participants, 90 male, 90 female.
Observations
Each participant will evaluate four savings decisions. So, we will have 720 observations (=4*180) for the acceptability-of-savings-decisions analysis.
Arms
For the evaluation-of-savings-decision vignettes, the between participant (cluster) treatment arms are Set A vs Set B vs Set C: - 240 observations from 60 participants (clusters) will relate to the Set A savings decisions (source of savings ambiguous, personal savings account) - 240 observations from 60 participants (clusters) will relate to the Set B savings decisions (source of savings business, personal savings account) - 240 observations from 60 participants (clusters) will relate to the Set C savings decisions (source of savings business, business savings account labelled appropriately) For the evaluation of savings decision vignettes, the within participant treatment arms of interest are saver-tells-spouse vs saver-does-not-tell-spouse: - 360 observations from 180 participants (clusters) will relate to vignettes in which the saver tells their spouse - 360 observations from 180 participants (clusters) will relate to vignettes in which the saver does not tell their spouse For the justification-of-husband-beating-wife questions: - 120 observations from 120 participants will relate to the husband discovering that the wife had been saving into a personal savings account without telling him (of these, in 60 cases the participant will have earlier been told about a scenario in which the wife's personal savings had come from her business, while in the other 60 cases they will have been told nothing about sources of wives' savings) - 60 observations from 60 participants will relate to the husband discovering that the wife had been saving into a savings account for her business without telling him.
Primary outcomes
When the focus is wives' and husbands' savings decisions, the outcome of interest is how socially acceptable participants think the decision is. When the focus is a husband beating his wife, the outcome of interest is whether participants think it is justifiable or not.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords