Defending Against Air Pollution in China

How to cite

Gong, Yazhen. 2023. "Defending Against Air Pollution in China." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010945. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10945-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yazhen Gong*

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010945
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10945-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2018-11-03 – 2019-03-31
Countries
China (Northeastern China)
JEL codes
Q53, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10945

Abstract

Information nudges have been widely used to influence behavior but there is a lack of understanding of the associated mechanisms and the optimal design. We distinguish active and passive information nudges and show that the former is more effective in promoting defensive behaviors such as outdoor time and mask-wearing against air pollution, and does so through reducing inattention. We conduct a large-scale field experiment through randomized control trails in Northern China with treatments of free masks and information nudges throughout a winter heating season when pollution was the heaviest. Unlike passive information nudges where participants were simply provided information about pollution and the associated health damages and required defensive measures, active nudges require participants to perform an easy task such as matching pollution levels with the corresponding health damages as well as the necessity to wear facemasks.
We find strong evidence that the active information nudges improve outdoor and mask-wearing behaviors and reduce respiratory and cardiovascular related hospital visits, whereas passive nudges do not have significant effects. We develop parametric and nonparametric measures of (daily) inattention to air pollution and inattention to the associated health damages, and find that both types of inattention lead to suboptimal defensive behaviors. Active information nudges reduce inattention levels, especially on high pollution days, and a sizable proportion of the active nudges’ positive effects is achieved through reduced inattention. In contrast, while providing free masks leads to more mask-wearing on smog days, it does not improve outdoor behavior or reduce inattention.
Our findings have important implications for promoting defensive behavior against pollution, and for the design of nudge intervention in general. Our study also highlights an important aspect of defensive behavior that is often ignored in the literature, namely the need to avoid adopting costly defensive behaviors in face of low or no pollution.

Intervention

Personal-level defensive measures against particulate matter (PM) pollution, including reducing outdoor time and wearing anti-pollution facemasks (APFs), are becoming increasingly important in both developing and developed nations. Nevertheless, there is a lack of empirical research on the overall efficiency of APFs and the size of the Peltzman effect in real-world settings. The uncertainty in the existing literature may have partly contributed to pushback against mask-wearing in the US and Australia when wildfires caused heavy PM pollution. Moreover, while information nudges have been widely applied as behavioral interventions to encourage desirable behaviors, there is a lack of understanding of the associated mechanisms and the optimal design. Acknowledging some of the gaps in existing literature, we conduct a large-scale field experiment through randomized control trials (RCTs) with 2,296 participants in Shenyang, the capital city of Liaoning Province in northeastern China. Intervention treatments include (i) financial incentives in the form of free masks; (ii) passive information nudge where each participant is provided with a brochure containing detailed information about PM pollution, its associated health damages, and required defensive measures; and (iii) three cascading information nudges where, on top of the brochure, the participants are asked to fill daily information about the air pollution level, checkmark the associated health effects, and/or the need to wear facemasks. Follow-up surveys are conducted to collect information from participants regarding their daily outdoor time and mask-wearing time, as well as their monthly health conditions throughout the entire winter heating season (from November 2018 through March 2019) when the pollution was the heaviest during the year.

Experimental design

Our experimental interventions involve one incentive treatment, namely a mask treatment, and three cascading information nudges, i.e. the passive information nudge, the active pollution information nudge and the active APF information nudge. The mask treatment provides three free KN95-type APFs while the three cascading information nudges are designed in the form of a combination of an information brochure and three different versions of calendars.

The “passive information nudge” provides each participant with one information brochure and version 1 of the calendar (V1 calendar). On the V1 calendar, participants are asked to fill out their daily information regarding how many hours they stay outdoors (outdoor time) and how many hours they wear facemasks when being outdoors (mask-wearing time) on each day during the whole winter heating season (from November 2018 through March 2019). The information brochure contains detailed information about smog and PM pollution, the health effects of the smog, defensive measures taken on smog days such as reduced outdoor activities and mask-wearing, roles of APFs in reducing the health effects of smog, different brands of APFs available on the market, the difference between APFs and regular cotton facemasks, and proper ways of wearing APFs. Each participant receiving an information brochure reads it through with verbal explanations from an enumerator during the baseline survey and then is asked to bring home one copy of the brochure after the survey. The “active pollution information nudge” provides one information brochure and a version 2 calendar (V2 calendar). The only difference between the passive information nudge and the active pollution information nudge is that the latter gives the V2 instead of the V1 calendar. The V2 calendar builds on the V1 calendar but requires the participants to carry out two additional tasks, i.e. checking one of four boxes corresponding to four intervals of daily mean AQI (i.e. 0-100, 101-200, 201-300, and 301 and higher) and one of four boxes corresponding to the health impact of the air quality (i.e. no impact, some impact, big impact, and very big impact). The “active APF information nudge” gives the participants one information brochure and a version 3 calendar (V3 calendar). The only difference between the active pollution information nudge and the active APF information nudges is the calendar version: the V3 calendar is like the V2 except that the V3 requires the participants to check an additional box among four boxes corresponding to the necessity of wearing an APF (i.e. no need, somewhat necessary, necessary, and very necessary).

The three different versions of calendars require different levels of effort made by the participants to fill out their daily information. Compared to the V1 calendar, the V2 and the V3 calendars need participants to make extra efforts to find out the daily AQI for a given day and then check a box indicating the health impact of the air quality on that day (both for the V2 and the V3) or an additional box showing the necessity of wearing facemasks on that day (only for the V3).

The additional tasks of filling out AQI information and checking boxes on the V2 or V3 calendars are relatively easy to be carried out. First, the participants can get easy access to daily AQI information, since nowadays in China, daily AQI information is routinely provided together with weather forecasts to the public through many media sources and public messages sent to cellphone users. Second, when checking boxes on the calendar, the participants can easily refer to a table presented at the lower corner of each page of the calendar. The table in the V2 has two columns: the first lists four intervals of daily mean AQI (i.e. 0-100, 101-200, 201-300, 301, and higher), and the second column lists the health impact corresponding to each interval of AQI. The table in V3 has three columns, including the same first two columns as those in V2, and a third column listing the necessity of wearing facemasks that corresponds to the information presented in the first and the second columns.

We use a 2 times 4 design to obtain eight experimental arms/interventions corresponding to different combinations of information nudges and the mask treatment. For the control group, only the V1 calendar is provided.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is conducted at the neighborhood level through the random assignment of eight experimental arms (interventions), which represent different combinations of a mask treatment and three cascading information nudges, to 40 neighborhoods. Half (20) of the neighborhoods (arms of 2, 4, 6, and 8) receive the mask treatment where each participant is given three free KN95-type APFs while another half (20) do not receive the APFs. Three-quarters (30) of the neighborhoods (arms of 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 8) receive three cascading information nudges: 10 neighborhoods (arms of 3 and 4) receive the passive information nudge, 10 neighborhoods (study arms 5 and 6) provided with the active pollution information nudge, and 10 neighborhoods (study arms 7 and 8) given the active APF information nudge. One quarter (10) of the neighborhoods (arms of 1 and 2) receive the V1 calendar but not the brochure; among them, five neighborhoods receive the APFs while the other five do not receive APFs. The control group is the neighborhoods only receiving the V1 calendar, but not the information brochure or free APFs.
Randomization unit
The randomization is conducted at the neighborhood level.
Clusters
40 neighborhoods. Using clustered sampling, a total of 40 neighborhoods are randomly drawn from a population of 3,785 neighborhoods in nine urban districts in Shenyang. The number of neighborhoods assigned to each district is determined according to the proportion of its population in the total population of the urban areas of the city. To control for potential spillover effects between adjacent neighborhoods, we randomly draw the neighborhoods by imposing a condition that the distance between any two of them is greater than 2 km.
Observations
The planned number of observations: 2,400 participants. In each neighborhood, 60 adult participants (18 years and older) are randomly drawn from the neighborhood roster, subject to a screening condition that they would spend the entire winter heating season of November 2018 − March 2019 in Shenyang and had lived in Shenyang for at least one year by November 2018. The screening condition is set with the consideration that some households in Shenyang spend the winter season in warm climatic zones in southern China. The sample is stratified into two age groups: one half is between 18 and 64 years old and the other half is 65 years and older.
Arms
Sample size: 2,296 participants With financial incentives provided for the participation, we recruit 2,296 participants out of the 2,400 participants who had been randomly selected and contacted through phones before the baseline survey and the RCTs and had agreed to participate in our study, achieving a participation rate of 95.63%.
Primary outcomes
defensive behaviors against air pollution
Secondary outcomes
Health outcomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords