Mobilizing for the Public Good: A Field Experiment on Community-Driven Development and Waste Management in El Salvador

How to cite

Jakob, Martina; Coccia, Carla. 2023. "Mobilizing for the Public Good: A Field Experiment on Community-Driven Development and Waste Management in El Salvador." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010913. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10913-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Martina Jakob* , Carla Coccia

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010913
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10913-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-08-25 – 2023-08-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H41, Q53, Q01
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10913

Abstract

Inadequately disposed waste is ubiquitous in low- and middle income countries, and causes serious environmental and health-related problems. In El Salvador, where streets and public spaces are typically highly contaminated by waste, littering poses a serious public goods problem at the community level. While the standard solution for public goods problems calls for an intervention by an external actor such as the state, a recent strand of literature has studied community driven development (CDD) as a potential alternative. Several studies have experimentally evaluated CDD initiatives, but their effectiveness has never been compared with that of the traditional non-participatory approach.
We will conduct a randomized controlled trial with 120 communities in El Salvador to address that question in the context of the littering problem. Communities will be assigned to either a control group or to one out of two treatments: (1) a top-down intervention where the streets will be cleaned by an external actor, or (2) a bottom-up intervention were a community facilitator is hired to raise awareness and to mobilize for collective clean-ups and a change in social norms regarding littering.
In all communities, we will conduct two types of measurements: (1) photos along the streets that will be evaluated using deep learning, (2) a short survey with a sample of 20 community members We will estimate both the immediate impact and the sustainability of the two interventions.

Intervention

Traditional intervention (top-down approach): A team of cleaners with a garbage truck visits each community once a month to collect garbage and clean all public spaces. Community members can also use the truck to dispose of their household waste.
Community-driven intervention (community-driven development approach): In each community, a facilitator is hired to organize workshops and activities to raise awareness about the problem and solve it through collective action. The facilitator also coordinates the implementation of clean-up campaigns by community members.

Both interventions have a duration of four months and roughly the same cost.

Experimental design

For this study, we selected 120 communities throughout Morazán based on (i) community size, (ii) safety, (iii) the presence of solid waste management problems, (iv) accessibility, and (v) geographical distance between communities to avoid spillover effects. Communities were then randomly assigned to our three experimental groups: (1) a traditional intervention, (2) a community-driven intervention, or (3) a control group.

In all communities, we conduct a baseline assessment prior to the interventions (wave 1), an endline assessment immediately after the interventions (wave 2), and a follow-up assessment four months later (wave 3). The assessments include (1) a contamination assessment and (2) a survey.

(1) Contamination assessment: Based on a detailed manual, enumerators take geo-tagged photos along the streets in all 120 communities. This procedure yields an average of about 540 photos per community for each of the three waves. Within a set distance along the streets, enumerators further make assessments of the overall cleanliness of the environment.

(2) Survey: In each community, a convenience sample of 20 villagers is selected to take part in all three waves of data collection. The survey has a duration of 10--15 minutes and covers questions about (i) attitudes, behaviors and perceptions of social norms regarding solid waste contamination, (ii) social capital within the community (e.g. social networks, trust, solidarity and organizations) as well as perceptions of living conditions and safety, and (iii) socio-demographic background (only baseline). The endline and follow-up assessments will further include questions about involvement in/observation of activities regarding solid waste management. Baseline surveys are conducted face-to-face in people's homes. For the endline and the follow-up survey, we conduct both phone or face-to-face interviews (depending on how each person can best be reached).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is conducted by the research team using the software R. Randomization is stratified by contamination level measured during the baseline assessment (terciles) and geographical zone (North, South, Center West, Center East).
Randomization unit
Communities
Clusters
120 communities
Observations
Contamination maps: - 65,000 photo locations, aggregated into approximately 100 raster cells per community (12,000) - 13,000 assessment locations Surveys: - 2400 community members (20 per community)
Arms
Treatment 1, Traditional intervention: 40 communities Treatment 2, community-driven intervention: 39 communities Control: 41 communities
Primary outcomes
(1) Waste contamination (2) Self-reported attitudes, behaviors and perceptions of social norms regarding solid waste contamination
Secondary outcomes
(1) Social capital (2) Trust in institutions (3) Living conditions (4) Safety
Sponsors
Name: Swiss National Science Foundation Location: Switzerland Url: https://www.snf.ch/en
Partners
Name: Consciente Partner_type: ngo Url: https://www.consciente.ch/en

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords