Re-imagining Education: Do Science Experiments Deliver Quality Education?
How to cite
Malik, Samreen; Parakash, Nishith; Bharti, Nitin Kumar; Mukhopadhyay, Abhiroop. 2023. "Re-imagining Education: Do Science Experiments Deliver Quality Education?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010902. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10902-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While many developing economies have made progress in providing access to education, the provision of quality education that delivers life-long learning, learning-how-to-learn, and developing the ability to apply knowledge to unfamiliar circumstances is essentially absent. In collaboration with the Agastya foundation, we conduct a randomized controlled trial in public schools in Uttar Pradesh (UP) to evaluate an intervention that provides alternative science-based pedagogy -- described as discovery-based pedagogy -- in 68 "treatment" schools which are then compared to 64 "control" schools. We aim to evaluate the impact of the intervention on students' life-long learning skills which are transferable and that go beyond academic success. Transferable skills are not taught using a textbook but have to be developed through the teaching and learning experience, which is the focus of this alternative pedagogy and we investigate whether the intervention resulted in improvement in students' overall creativity, curiosity, confidence, commitment and content-based learning but also in terms of scientific skills.
Intervention
The intervention is designed for students in lower-middle grades (grades 6th, 7th and 8th) in public schools where pedagogy follows a traditional approach-where the teacher instructs and students follow. In contrast, this intervention is based on a child-centric, guided discovery/inquiry-based pedagogical style where students are guided to discover their own learning experiences - through several project-based tasks and science experiments. In particular, instructors start by presenting a simple science problem, and through inquisition and hands-on experience with practical experimentation, students are guided to discover the solution to the presented problem. In any session, the student engagement exceeds the uni-direction instruction time, where for at least 75% of the time, students lead the discussions.
Through this intervention, we aim to evaluate whether an alternative learning method (described above; more details follow) impacts students' content-based learning, confidence, curiosity, and creativity. All of these are important inputs for developing critical thinking. While we expect some small effect on academic content-based learning (such as scores on science tests we conduct), we hypothesize that the intervention can have positive effects on students' self-confidence, curiosity, commitment and creativity. Such skills learned through science pedagogy can impact students' engagement with other subjects, and we aim to evaluate this intervention's spillover effect on their engagement in other subjects. For the direct and spillover effect, we consider various mechanisms such as parents' aspirations for their children, socio-economic factors, and biological factors driving our results. We collect this information in the baseline and the endline (to be conducted in 2023).
Experimental design
There are two types of interventions in the study, which are similar with respect to the pedagogical approach but differ in terms of resources employed. The intervention provides a hands-on experience to students where they are fully involved in the experiments conducted. The intervention is carried out between August'22 to March'23.
Treatment 1 -- Mobile Science Lab (MSL):
Under this intervention, a mobile van with science experiment kits visits treatment schools with three foundation-hired and trained instructors. The instructor gives a 4-hour session per month to each classroom (grades 6 to 8).
Treatment 2 -- Lab on Bike (LoB): Under this intervention, a motorbike with science experiment kits visits treatment schools with one foundation-hired and trained instructor. The instructor gives a 2-hour session per month to each classroom (grades 6 to 8).
Control: Schools assigned to the control group do not receive the intervention and continue with traditional textbook-based teaching.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.