Development, Implementation, and Evaluation of a National Cross-generational Strategy to Support Introduction of the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccine and Utilization of Cervical Cancer Screening in Nepal

How to cite

Kaljee, Linda; Joshi, Seema; Lal, Bibek Kumar; Bajracharya, Deepak. 2023. "Development, Implementation, and Evaluation of a National Cross-generational Strategy to Support Introduction of the Human Papillomavirus (HPV) Vaccine and Utilization of Cervical Cancer Screening in Nepal." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010896. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10896-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Linda Kaljee* , Seema Joshi , Bibek Kumar Lal , Deepak Bajracharya

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010896
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10896-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-02-08 – 2024-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10896

Abstract

Since the approval and introduction of human papillomavirus (HPV) vaccines in 2006, the burden of new cervical cancer cases has steadily grown in low- and middle-income countries (LMIC). A 2016 study estimated that only 1% of women receiving the HPV vaccine worldwide were from LMICs and that as of 2020, the majority of the 604,000 new cervical cancer cases in the world occurred in LMICs. At this time, the Nepal Ministry of Health and Population (MOHP), Family Welfare Division is planning to apply to GAVI in September 2022 to initiate the introduction of HPV into the national immunization plan. It is anticipated that in mid-to-late 2023 HPV introduction will start in 8 to 12 districts and then move to national coverage.

In Nepal, cervical cancer is the most frequently diagnosed cancer among women and contributes to the highest number of cancer-related mortalities in the country. Limited data are available regarding women’s utilization of cervical cancer screening in Nepal, however one study suggests that only 15% of women surveyed had been screened. The Nepal government has prioritized cervical cancer screening as a free-of-cost priority program; however, multiple socio-cultural and economic factors affect screening including lack of knowledge about cervical cancer both within the healthcare professions and general population, social taboos regarding discussion of sexual and reproductive health, and limited laboratory facilities.

The proposed study is designed to adapt/develop a context-driven strategy to decrease risks of HPV infection and cervical cancer in Nepal through an integrated vaccination and cervical cancer screening campaign. The program will implement a cross-generational approach to encourage vaccination of young girls and screening of their mothers, aunts, grandmothers and other women in the communities. The key objectives are: 1) Assess policy and programmatic, health system, and community factors that affect intention to uptake HPV vaccines for girls ages 9 to 14 and use of cervical cancer screening services among women 30 to 60 years old. 2) Utilize data to adapt/develop: i) a healthcare provider training program in relation to HPV vaccine and cervical cancer screening; and, ii) a cross-generational comprehensive social mobilization and communication strategy to support HPV vaccine uptake and cervical cancer screening. 3) Implement and conduct a randomized control trial of the healthcare provider and community interventions during the initial roll out of HPV vaccines in selected districts. 4) Engage with policy makers, program managers, health care providers and community members (parents/adolescents) through scientific and community advisory boards (SAB/CABs) and a post-project dissemination workshop

Intervention

Adaptation/development of interventions including training for healthcare providers and a cross-generational community social mobilization and communication strategy focused on HPV uptake and use of cervical cancer screening services.
The research team will review existing healthcare provider trainings focused on HPV vaccines and cervical cancer screening from the MOHP and other organizations (e.g., WHO) in Nepal, as well as other relevant materials/trainings available within the scientific literature that may be adaptable for use. In terms of the latter, we will focus on programs that have been evaluated and shown to be effective in terms of HPV vaccine awareness, uptake, and/or use of cervical cancer screening.
For the community programs, we will utilize a literature review of community interventions to increase uptake of HPV vaccine and/or cervical cancer screening. We will focus on evidence-based interventions and those implemented in LMIC and the South/Southeast Asian region. Our initial review of the literature suggests some of the following approaches and intervention characteristics that could be adapted for our cross-generational strategy.

1. Social mobilization models across generations.
2. Utilization of trusted community leaders and healthcare providers. As previously noted, healthcare providers were the most trusted sources of information about the COVID-19 vaccine in our hesitancy study in Nepal. Engagement of schools and educators has also been a successful approach in delivering information about HPV vaccines.
3. Focus on HPV vaccines as a means of cancer prevention.
4. Use of social media to provide information about the HPV vaccine. In our COVID-19 vaccine study, 96% and 85% of 18-to-30-year-olds and 31-to-59-year-olds respondents reported using Facebook.
5. Offering different options for cervical cancer screening – in particular, for self-sample collection.
6. Regular contact and reminders from clinic staff to women who have missed an appointment or are due for a screening.

Experimental design

The study is a RCT including randomization of 4 study sites into intervention (2) and control (2). Evaluation of the intervention will include a baseline survey and a six-month post intervention survey. The study population includes healthcare workers, parents of girls 9 to 14 years, and their daughters (9 to 14 years).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization will be conducted prior to collection of the baseline data (Phase 1, Assessment). From the 8 to 12 districts which will be part of the initial HPV vaccine roll out, we will stratify by characteristics (e.g., rural/urban, province, population characteristics). Once stratified, we will randomly select 2 urban and 2 rural districts. We will then randomly select 1 urban and 1 rural district as the intervention arm and 1 urban and 1 rural as control. Within these districts we will randomly select 4 study wards per district (total 16 wards). The parent/guardian-daughter dyads will be randomly selected from municipality/ward offices, primary care clinics, and school rosters. Lists of potential participants will be put into a SPSS file and the software randomization process will be used to select participants by ward. The sample size is 60 dyads/ward (see Section 2.7 Sample Size calculation). To address refusals and potential attrition between baseline and post-intervention, we will increase the initial sample by 20% (N=72).
Randomization unit
There are two levels of randomization. Randomization of study 16 wards into control (8) / intervention (8). Within each study ward, parent-daughter dyads will be randomly selected to participate in the evaluation.
Clusters
16 study wards in 4 districts
Observations
960 parent-daughter dyads
Arms
8 wards per arm and 480 parent-daughter dyads per arm
Primary outcomes
The primary outcome variable will be likelihood to report discussions about HPV vaccines and cervical cancer screening with patients/parents of patients. Additional variables will include: 1) knowledge and awareness of HPV, HPV vaccine, cervical cancer, and cervical cancer screening; 2) perceptions of disease severity and patients’ vulnerability to HPV/cervical cancer; and, 3) perceptions of support at the health facility and through the health system to facilitate HPV vaccine administration and cervical cancer services; and, 4) vaccine hesitancy constructs (confidence, convenience, complacency) Parents: The primary outcome variables will be intention to have their daughter receive the HPV vaccine once available within their district and use of available cervical cancer screening services/intention to use cervical cancer screening services. Additional variables will include: 1) knowledge and awareness of HPV, HPV vaccine, cervical cancer and cervical cancer screening; 2) utilization of other vaccines (e.g., EPI); 3) utilization of reproductive sexual health services (e.g., pre-natal care, trained birth assistance); and 4) vaccine hesitancy constructs The primary outcome variable will be willingness to receive the HPV vaccine once available within their district. Additional variables will include: 1) knowledge and awareness of HPV, HPV vaccine and cervical cancer; 2) experience with receiving other vaccines and concerns about receiving vaccines (e.g., fear of needles); 3) perceptions of severity of HPV and cervical cancer; 4) perceptions of likelihood of being infected with HPV/being diagnosed with cervical cancer later in life

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords