Building Markets in Remote Places: Evidence from Formerly FARC-Controlled Areas of Colombia
How to cite
Pelnik, Carolyn; Brooks, Wyatt; Kaboski, Joseph; Bartkus, Viva. 2023. "Building Markets in Remote Places: Evidence from Formerly FARC-Controlled Areas of Colombia." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010892. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10892-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Decades of conflict in rural Colombia – combined with the rough terrain and meager transportation infrastructure that are typical of remote and low-income regions – have eroded market ties between rural farmers and wealthier market centers. This poses a challenge to rural livelihoods and coca eradication, both components of Colombia's 2016 Peace Accords. We use a randomized controlled trial to assess the impact of a market-making program, a supply chain intervention that integrates commercialization with agricultural extension practices to connect farmers to buyers of legal crops. We study the market-making program alone and the market-making program plus a cash intervention, which more closely mirrors the Colombian government's current practice. Specifically, we ask: (1) what is the effect of a supply chain intervention that connects coca-growing farmers to buyers of alternative crops on the composition and quantity of household income, coca growth, and social outcomes such as self-efficacy, trust, and security, (2) is there a differential effect of implementing the supply chain intervention alongside a cash intervention that guarantees participants a minimum income, and (3) which version of the program is most cost-effective?
Intervention
The interventions that we test include a market-making program implemented by our partner non-governmental organization and a cash intervention. The market-making program combines commercialization and agricultural extension practices to connect farmers to buyers of legal crops. Through locally deployed extension agents, the program organizes farmers in rural regions of high coca cultivation into associations. They identify cash crops suited to local agricultural and economic conditions. Next, the NGO invests in inputs (e.g., seeds, tools, training) and infrastructure (e.g., fertilizer production plants, trucks for transport) needed to realize the production of new crops and deliver them to market. The extension agents also train association members to organize regular farmers’ markets in regional capitals and contract directly with large purchasers, such as supermarkets.
The cash intervention offers households the opportunity to do paid work to support the market-making intervention at an above-market wage. This intervention is very similar to India’s widely studied National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA) program and guarantees recipients a minimum income of $550 total over the duration of the market-making program.
Experimental design
We randomize market-making at the level of the vereda (similar to a village). We randomize the cash intervention, which guarantees $550 in total wages to participants, at the individual level. Our sample consists of 1,800 households across 90 veredas in the Guaviare department. We randomly assign 30 veredas to the control group, 30 veredas to receive only the market-making intervention, and 30 veredas to receive market-making and where households are also eligible for the cash intervention. Within the last group, 10 veredas are randomly designated as "high intensity", where 13 individuals per vereda are randomly selected to receive cash. The other 20 veredas are randomly designated as "low intensity", where 1 individual per vereda is randomly selected to receive cash.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.