Evaluating the Impact of Preschool on Patience, Time Consistency and Commitment Demand

How to cite

Chuan, Amanda; Samek, Anya; Samujjwala, Shreemayi. 2023. "Evaluating the Impact of Preschool on Patience, Time Consistency and Commitment Demand." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010891. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10891-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Amanda Chuan* , Anya Samek , Shreemayi Samujjwala

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010891
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10891-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2015-09-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
I21, I24, J24, I26
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10891

Abstract

We use a field experiment to evaluate patience, time inconsistency and commitment demand among young children. We first show that patience at ages 5-10 positively predicts reading scores up to 4 years later, even when controlling for cognitive and executive function assessment scores. In contrast, time inconsistency and commitment demand do not predict reading scores. Second, we evaluate whether preschool affects patience. We leverage a field experiment that randomized children to different preschool curricula. We find that children who were offered the preschool curriculum focused on self-regulation make patient decisions in both periods of the experiment, whereas control children who were not offered the preschool intervention do not. Further, preschool helps children use commitment devices to manage their time inconsistency, but does not affect time inconsistency directly.

Intervention

We use a pre-existing randomized controlled trial, called the Chicago Heights Early Childhood Center (CHECC). CHECC randomized children to a preschool, a Parent Academy workshop, or the control group. Our paper will only use the preschool and control groups.

Within preschool, children were randomized to one of three curricula. Children who participated in 2010-2012 were randomized to either the Tools of the Mind curriculum or the Literacy Express curriculum. Preschool children who participated in 2012-2014 all received the CogX curriculum. The control group receives no daycare or preschool.

After children leave preschool, we revisit them in the elementary school classroom to elicit time preferences. Our task involves giving children the opportunity to choose between one glow bracelet tomorrow (sooner) or two glow bracelets the next day (later). We then surprise children with the opportunity to change their mind the next day, when the sooner option becomes available immediately. This enables us to capture patience and time inconsistency. The following week, we repeat the experiment. The only difference in execution is that after children make their first choice between one glow bracelet tomorrow or two glow bracelets the next day, we offer them a commitment device to help them stick to the option of two glow bracelets later.

Experimental design

We use a pre-existing randomized controlled trial, called the Chicago Heights Early Childhood Center (CHECC). CHECC randomized children to a preschool, a Parent Academy workshop, or the control group. Our paper will only use the preschool and control groups.

Within preschool, children were randomized to one of three curricula. Children who participated in 2010-2012 were randomized to either the Tools of the Mind curriculum or the Literacy Express curriculum. Preschool children who participated in 2012-2014 all received the CogX curriculum. The control group receives no daycare or preschool.

Design details

Randomization method
public lottery
Randomization unit
Family. For families with one child of preschool age in 2010-2014, this will be equivalent to randomizing at the child level. For families with more than one child of preschool age in 2010-2014, all children will be randomized to the same treatment.
Clusters
2000 families
Observations
2000 families, corresponding to approximately 2000 children
Arms
1132 in Control; 133 in Tools of the Mind; 136 in Literacy Express; 263 in CogX
Primary outcomes
We measure patience by whether children choose the two bracelet option when they must wait for either option. We measure inconsistency by whether children change their mind when the one bracelet option becomes available immediately. We measure commitment demand using whether they take up the commitment device. We correlate these measures with future academic and behavioral measures. These include standardized reading and math scores, number of disciplinary referrals, patience in future tasks, and risk preferences in future tasks.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords