Do energy-saving nudges deliver during high-price periods? Field experimental evidence from the European Energy Crisis

How to cite

Werthschulte, Madeline; Kesternich, Martin; Tinnefeld, Vicky Leoni. 2023. "Do energy-saving nudges deliver during high-price periods? Field experimental evidence from the European Energy Crisis." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010890. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10890-2.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Madeline Werthschulte* , Martin Kesternich , Vicky Leoni Tinnefeld

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010890
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10890-2.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-10-01 – 2023-04-01
Countries
Germany ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10890

Abstract

Urged by the European Energy Crisis and the threatening consequences of severe natural gas shortages, energy providers launched gas-saving initiatives incorporating financial incentives to reduce residential natural gas consumption. In collaboration with one of Germany’s largest energy providers, we conducted a natural field experiment (N = 2,598) to evaluate the effectiveness of a behaviorally-guided co-design of such a gas-saving initiative by implementing two established behavioral instruments -- reminders of gas saving intentions and descriptive norm feedback. Our findings show limited effectiveness of the behavioral instruments during the high-price period. The feedback risks a ``boomerang effect” among households with above-average initial savings, who reduce their conservation efforts in response. The reminder does not significantly enhance savings in our main specifications, yet, realizes 1 percentage point savings in alternate models refining for outliers. Potential mechanisms include a significant intention-action gap and misperceived effectiveness of energy-saving actions, which are not alleviated by the reminder.

Experimental design

With the need of drastic energy consumption reductions in winter 2022/2023, our cooperation partner launched an energy savings program. The program started in October 2022, and all participating households will receive 5 cents for every kilowatt-hour of natural gas saved until April 2023 compared to previous years’ natural gas consumption. In addition, bonuses of 20 (40) euros are promised if all participating households achieve savings of 10% (15%).

By October 2022, about 2500 households signed up for this program. During the program, participants receive two mailings (1) in mid-December to inform them about their current savings and the savings of all participating households, (2) in mid-February to inform them about gas storage levels in Germany.

Our natural field experiment randomizes the information content provided in these two mailings. While a control group receives the standard mailings described above, a treatment group receives additional information. This additional information is designed to remind participants about (i) their initial energy saving plans, (ii) the financial incentive of saving energy, and (iii) their planned energy saving actions to achieve these savings.

We thereby connect the plan-making and reminder literature. While making precise plans has proven to be effective to follow through with good intentions, these type of nudges often lose effectiveness after a few months. This might be particularly true in the German energy context, as household typically do not have feedback systems that inform them about consumption and achieved savings. Our intervention thus aims to remind households of the plans they made at the time they signed up for the energy savings program.

We will estimate the impact of this intervention on individual natural gas consumption in the period from October 2022-April 2023, and the change in natural gas consumption compared to the previous years. Further secondary outcomes will be (1) interest in energy saving webinars and (2) stated energy saving actions undertaken. We measure the interest in energy saving webinars through clicks in the mailings on links redirecting to the sign-up for such webinars. We will run a survey in April 2023 to ask participants for the energy saving actions they undertook during the winter to save energy.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization by computer
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
2535 (number of individuals participating in the energy savings program)
Observations
2535 (number of individuals participating in the energy savings program)
Arms
1267 (50:50 for control- and reminder-mailing)
Primary outcomes
Natural gas consumption (in kWh) Change in natural gas consumption compared to previous years
Secondary outcomes
Interest in additional energy saving webinars (yes/no) Executed energy saving actions (yes/no)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords