Improving match quality to college majors and impacts on student outcomes in high school

How to cite

Yuan, Fei; Pei, Yuan. 2023. "Improving match quality to college majors and impacts on student outcomes in high school." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010870. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10870-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Fei Yuan* , Yuan Pei

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010870
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10870-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-12-19 – 2025-07-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10870

Abstract

Choosing the best-fit major is a substantial challenge for many students, especially those in education systems with less flexibility in major-switching. This experiment studies how high school students evaluate various characteristics of college majors, and the impact on their academic preparation for college and other socioemotional outcomes. I conduct experiments on grade 10 students (i.e., first-year high school students) in China. First, I examine high school students' expectations for intended college majors. Using an online survey, I ask whether they have intended majors, the primary reasons they consider those majors, their personal tastes for those majors, and their (un)certainty and knowledge about the wage and non-wage aspects of the majors. Second, I use an experiment to provide students with tutorials on their top three majors. Each tutorial covers course requirements, relevant high school subjects, career options, and mini-lectures about key concepts and applications of a college major. I study how students update their expectations for their intended college majors and change their behavior in academic preparation, goal-setting, and the choice of major. The results of the experiment will help us better understand how high school students make college major choices.

Intervention

The intervention consists of three online tutorials on college majors. Each tutorial is a 20-60 minute video, covering course requirements, relevant high school subjects, career options, and mini-lectures about key concepts and applications of a college major.
There are two treatment arms of this intervention. (1) In the Information-only treatment arm, students receive the first session of the tutorials, including course requirements, relevant high school subjects, and career options of a major. (2) In the Full treatment arm, students receive all the components of the tutorials.

Experimental design

There are four stages of this experiment. First, using an online survey, I ask whether they have intended majors, the primary reasons they consider those majors, their personal tastes for those majors, and their (un)certainty and knowledge about the wage and non-wage aspects of the majors. Second, I use an experiment to provide students with tutorials on their top three majors. Each tutorial covers course requirements, relevant high school subjects, career options, and mini-lectures about key concepts and applications of a college major. Students in the treatment are randomly assigned to the (1) Information-only treatment group or (2) Full treatment group. Students in the Information-only group receive the first session of the tutorials, including course requirements, relevant high school subjects, and career options of a major, while students in the Full treatment arm receive all the components of the tutorials. Third, I survey the students one month after the intervention to study how students update their expectations for their intended college majors and change their behavior in academic preparation, goal-setting, and the choice of major. Fourth, I follow up with the students in six months to study the medium-term effects of the intervention on the primary outcomes.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
The experiment used a two-stage randomization design. The first-stage randomization was at the classroom level. Classrooms were randomly assigned to one of the three groups: high-saturation treatment, low-saturation treatment, and control. Within the high- and low-saturation groups, half of the classrooms will receive the information-only treatment, and half of the classrooms will receive the full tutorial treatment. In the high-saturation treatment group, 100% of students will get the treatment. In the low-saturation treatment group, 50% of students will get the treatment and the randomization was done at the individual level.
Clusters
63 classrooms
Observations
2,500 high school students from 62 classrooms
Arms
18 classrooms control, 23 classrooms information-only treatment, 21 classrooms full treatment
Primary outcomes
Student's choice of intended college majors, choice of elective subjects for the college entrance exam, academic motivation, test scores, self-efficacy for college-major decision-making and goal-setting
Secondary outcomes
mapping between college majors and electives on the college entrance exam, mapping between college majors and careers, knowledge about course requirements and contents of college majors, mapping between college majors and high school subjects, educational aspiration, expectation for wages after college

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords