A Field Experiment to Encourage Energy Saving Behavior Using Different Defaults and Dynamic Pricing

How to cite

Ishihara, Takunori; Kido, Daido; Ida, Takanori. 2023. "A Field Experiment to Encourage Energy Saving Behavior Using Different Defaults and Dynamic Pricing." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010811. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10811-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Takunori Ishihara* , Daido Kido , Takanori Ida

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010811
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10811-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-01-23 – 2023-02-06
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10811

Abstract

We study the effects of treatments with dynamic pricing (DP) on electricity-saving behavior. Furthermore, we analyze whether different defaults lead to different treatment effects.

Intervention

Dynamic Pricing

Experimental design

【Survey 1】
In conjunction with a Web-based research company, we conducted a survey of monitors to obtain household demographics such as gender, age, and income of household members, as well as their use of home appliances. The survey was conducted online through a Web-based research company. At the beginning of the survey, we asked them for their consent to participate in this research experiment. Only those who have given their consent to participate will be included in the following experiments. In addition, we will pay a reward to the participants of the experiment for their participation in this survey and the following experiments and surveys.

[Experiment]
We randomly divide the monitors of a survey company (3,300 households) that obtained consent to participate in the experiment in Survey 1 above into 10 groups. Details of each group are as follows.
1. Control group:
No intervention.
2. Compulsory treatment group:
They offer compulsory DP.
3. Opt-in group 1:
Default is no DP. If they opt-in, they receive DP.
4. Opt-in group 2:
Default is no DP. Opt-in users will receive 300 yen and they receive DP.
5. Opt-in group 3:
Default is no DP. Opt-in users will receive 600 yen and they receive DP.
6. Opt-in group 4:
Default is no DP. Opt-in users will receive 900 yen and they receive DP.
7. Opt-in group 5:
Default is no DP. Opt-in users will receive 1,200 yen and they receive DP.
8. Opt-out group 1:
Default is DP. If they opt-out, they do not receive DP.
9. Opt-out group 2:
Default is DP. If they opt-out, they do not receive DP.
10. Opt-out group 3:
Default is DP. If they opt out, they receive 600 yen and do not receive a DP.

We will obtain the 30-minute electricity consumption data (HEMS data: November-February 2022) from participants for the event period and the periods before and after the event through the monitoring company. Participants in this experiment will receive treatments by DP during the week of January 23-29, 2023. We set the upper and lower prices of DP at ¥100/kWh and ¥13/kWh, respectively. We also set the base price at 30 yen/kWh. We then calculate the payment for the participants who received the intervention during the event period calculated at the base price and calculated at the DP respectively. Finally, we pay the participants the difference between them as a reward for saving electricity (maximum: 2,000 yen worth of points).

[Survey 2]
For those who assigned to the above control group or the opt-in / out group that did not opt-in for the DP, we will conduct a survey asking them if they are home or not home on a particular day (February 5 and 6). We will pay respondents $300 worth of points as a reward for this survey.

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
household level randomization
Clusters
3,300 households
Observations
1,000,000
Arms
330 control, 330 compulsory treatment, 330 opt-in 1, 330 opt-in 2, 330 opt-in 3, 330 opt-in 4, 330 opt-in 5, 330 opt-out 1, 330 opt-out 2, 330 opt-out 3.
Primary outcomes
Energy usage (30 minutes interval HEMS data)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords