Remote Care for Remote Areas: The Impact of Telehealth in Rural India
How to cite
Dahlstrand, Amanda; Guariso, Andrea; Deserranno, Erika. 2023. "Remote Care for Remote Areas: The Impact of Telehealth in Rural India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010787. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10787-2.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Remote areas in low-income countries have poor access to quality healthcare. One challenge in developing state capacity in remote areas is the difficulty in attracting skilled workers (like doctors or nurses), to which a common solution is to engage less skilled workers (community health workers). A new solution is to bring higher-skilled professionals to rural areas through digital technology. Telehealth, which connects patients to qualified healthcare professionals via phone, provides a new opportunity for governments to reach remote areas with high-quality healthcare services at relatively low cost. Although the popularity of telehealth has dramatically increased since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, there is to date no causal evidence of its impacts in low-income countries.
This project aims to provide the first experimental evidence on the impact of telehealth on healthcare utilization and health outcomes in low-income countries. The impact is ex-ante ambiguous: telehealth may expand access to healthcare in areas previously underserved by the health system, but it might also crowd out in-person care and lead to an overall drop in healthcare utilization by those most in need, who might be unable or unwilling to connect remotely with a health professional. The project will take place in 400 rural Indian villages that will be randomized into receiving telehealth or not, with or without a local facilitator, who will assist patients in connecting to the call and follow up with them after the visit. We will learn whether and under which conditions telehealth improves access and health outcomes for rural populations, and how it affects the divide in access by e.g. socioeconomic status and age.
Intervention
Telehealth connects patients to qualified health care professionals via phone. Although its popularity dramatically increased since the onset of the COVID-19 pandemic, there is limited rigorous evidence of its impact. In particular, the impact of telehealth on health access and healthcare inequality in low-income countries is ex-ante ambiguous. On the one hand, telehealth could allow individuals currently out of reach of the official health system -- e.g., because of their remote location or because of prevailing norms -- to access quality healthcare providers, thus improving the quality of care and equalizing access. On the other hand, telehealth might crowd out in-person care, with potential negative consequences on health outcomes for those individuals who do not engage with technology, who are not e-literate, or who have little trust in modern medicine to start with (e.g., women, the elderly, the poor). This may result in telehealth excluding individuals who might need care most, exacerbating inequality in healthcare.
Given the potential barriers to the utilization of telehealth in low-income settings, the presence of local “facilitators” may be crucial to its success. First, local facilitators may attenuate the digital divide by allowing marginalized individuals, including women with low power in the household, to contact the doctor and nurse through a smartphone that has access to the internet. Second, local facilitators may allow for more “continuity of care”, an aspect which is often lacking in telehealth programs that prioritize the “speed of care” (i.e., patients meeting with the first available provider even if that provider is unknown to them) and which might matter especially in contexts with low trust in modern medicine. Finally, local facilitators may complement telehealth services by monitoring the evolution of health conditions of patients that require frequent follow-ups (e.g., noncommunicable diseases).
India provides an ideal study setting, both because of the vast potential user base in need of telehealth services and because recent years have seen a rapid diffusion of telehealth providers. We will study the impact of the arrival of a new telehealth provider in a random subset of the 400 study villages in rural Bihar. The new health provider (Healing Fields Foundation, HFF) will introduce two (randomized) alternative versions of telehealth: with and without a facilitator, i.e., a community health worker that will help community members connect with a doctor remotely. We aim to study:
• What is the causal impact of telehealth on access to health services and health outcomes among people in rural areas?
• Does the presence of a facilitator increase the spreading and utilization of telehealth?
• Which types of patients are more likely to use telehealth with vs. without the facilitator? Does the impact differ across e.g. socioeconomic status and age groups?
Experimental design
The study will take place in 400 villages in the state of Bihar, India. The study will be a 2x2 field experiment, which will be implemented after the baseline data collection, in collaboration with Healing Fields Foundation (HFF), an NGO which recently launched a telehealth program that relies on community health workers (CHWs) as “facilitators”. We will take advantage of the planned expansion of HFF activities in the study region, to randomly select the villages that will be reached first by the program. Each study village will be randomly assigned to one of four groups of equal size:
• Control (C): status quo (no HFF telehealth and no HFF CHW);
• Telehealth + CHW (T1): HFF will provide telehealth and will recruit and train a CHW, who will be in charge of facilitating it;
• Telehealth only (T2): HFF will provide telehealth services that community members can directly utilize, but won’t recruit any CHW;
• CHW only (T3): HFF will recruit and train a CHW, but there will be no HFF telehealth services.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.