Can graduation programs be greener? Evidence from the BOMA program
How to cite
Alix-Garcia, Jennifer; Karlan, Dean; Cramer, Kim Fe; Brune, Lasse. 2023. "Can graduation programs be greener? Evidence from the BOMA program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010786. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10786-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The Ultra Poor Graduation approach is designed to graduate households out of extreme poverty to a more stable state. The BOMA Project has adapted the graduation approach for the arid and semi-arid lands (ASALs) of Africa with their Rural Entrepreneur Access Project (REAP). In 2019 BOMA created “Green” REAP as a way for communities to minimize the negative environmental impact of business activities, spur positive engagement with the environment, adapt to the climate crisis and mitigate the impact of climate change on the community. Green REAP aims to simultaneously move households out of extreme poverty and create positive environmental impacts. Its three main pillars are greening livelihoods (using green enterprises to graduate the ultra-poor out of poverty), greening systems (advocating for policy and structural changes to create an enabling environment for sustainable resource management and climate-neutral micro, small, and medium enterprises) and greening values (changing social norms, attitudes, and practices regarding natural resource management).
We are conducting a multi-arm clustered randomized evaluation of Green REAP with three arms; Standard REAP, Green REAP and control. The evaluation will establish whether: Green REAP is able to maintain (or increase) the poverty and welfare impacts of Standard REAP while achieving additional environmental benefits. Participation in Green REAP encourages households to: engage in environmentally friendly businesses such as beekeeping or gum and resin harvesting; reduce household dependence on charcoal production; improve livestock grazing practices; and fortify community resource management groups.
The evaluation will be randomized at the community level. It will measure community-level outcomes (such as the intensity of observed activities in the forest) as well as individual household outcomes (such as income, food security, environmental attitudes, forest extraction activities, and participation in green value chains and community forest associations).
Intervention
The Ultra Poor Graduation approach is a 24-month program that provides beneficiaries with a holistic set of services including livelihood trainings, productive asset transfers, consumption support, savings services, basic health services, and life skills coaching. The BOMA Project has adapted the graduation approach for the arid and semi-arid lands (ASALs) of Africa with their Rural Entrepreneur Access Project (REAP). As in other graduation programs, communities nominate their poorest, most vulnerable members to participate in the program. Participants receive financial and life skills training and mentoring to manage and grow their business. They also contribute to a savings pool, which they can access as needed to cope with shocks or to invest in expanding their business. REAP is delivered in groups both for savings and business: REAP participants form small business groups, draft a business plan, and receive a cash grant to start a small business.
The “Green” REAP program was created as a way for communities to minimize the negative environmental impact of business activities, spur positive engagement with the environment, adapt to the climate crisis and mitigate the impact of climate change on the community. Green REAP establishes environment-neutral or environment-supporting businesses, “green” businesses, as a pathway out of extreme poverty. Further, community resources management groups (community forest associations, natural resource management groups, etc.) in Green REAP villages will receive additional training in how to manage forest and pasture resources for climate resiliency. With Green REAP, the BOMA Project seeks to simultaneously move households out of extreme poverty and create positive environmental impacts.
Experimental design
This is a multi-arm clustered randomized evaluation in 105 clusters with the following arms:
1. Standard REAP: 35 clusters
2. Green REAP: 35 clusters
3. Control: 35 clusters
Our evaluation will be randomized at the community level. Both treatment and control households will be screened through the same selection process to ensure the groups are comparable. The evaluation includes the following steps.
1. BOMA Project screens households in treatment and control clusters and provides a list of eligible households to IPA.
2. IPA conducts baseline survey with sample households in all study communities, plus additional data collection as needed
3. IPA randomly assigns each geographic cluster to one of the selected treatments, or to control, using a computer
4. BOMA Project launches implementation
5. IPA conducts a midline survey to capture short-term changes in participant activities such as business launches and incorporation of environmental components
6. BOMA Project concludes intervention
7. IPA conducts endline socioeconomic surveys with households and businesses
We will sample a small number of ineligible households in clusters in order to identify spillover effects.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.