Framing urban tolls

How to cite

Arlinghaus, Johanna; Konc, Théo; Mattauch, Linus; Sommer, Stephan. 2023. "Framing urban tolls." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010783. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10783-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Johanna Arlinghaus* , Théo Konc , Linus Mattauch , Stephan Sommer

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010783
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10783-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2023-01-30 – 2023-03-31
Countries
Private
JEL codes
D30, H23, H41, H71, I14, J22, O18, Q53
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10783

Abstract

In this project, we analyse how different policy framings affect citizens' acceptance of urban tolls in two major European metropolitan areas: Paris-Ile de France and the Berlin-Brandenburg agglomeration. Furthermore, we investigate heterogeneity in views based on urban vs. suburban residence, trust in institutions and political views. To this end, we implement a large-scale survey of a total of 4000 urban and suburban households, representative for gender, education and age across the two metropolitan areas with the survey company respondi/bilendi. Within the survey, we randomize in-built video treatments to inform respondents of the tolls’ expected effects on (i) air pollution, (ii) time savings or (iii) greenhouse gas emissions. The effects of the treatment videos on support for an urban toll are compared to a control group, which receives a video with largely uninformative content. The research design allows testing a range of hypotheses with regards to the effects of the different treatments on policy support, including across different population groups (e.g. urban vs suburban, Berlin-Brandenburg vs Paris Ile de France) as well as hypotheses relating to interactions of these main hypothesized effects with several individual characteristics, such as political attitudes and mobility behavior.

Intervention

We use a questionnaire with in-built video treatments to analyse the effect of different policy framings on the support of urban tolls. After screening for the respective quotas within the questionnaire, we ask respondents a suite of questions on their personal background as well as on their personal and political attitudes and their mobility behavior. After these questions we introduce the topic of congestion prices. Specifically, we provide information on the functioning of urban tolls by displaying short video messages within the survey. After the video messages, we tell respondents to consider the introduction of an urban toll in their city and ask whether or not they would support this policy. We use the magnitude of the London congestion charge upon its introduction in 2003 as an anchoring price. We then ask a range of questions on revenue use, predicted behavior change as well as the potential winners and losers of the policy, including in the urban and suburban context.

Experimental design

In each city, the sample is divided in four randomised groups, three of which are shown a treatment video on the potential effects of urban tolls. The control group likewise views a city-specific video, but the contents bear no relation to urban tolls. The content of the video messages is delivered in French and in German, respectively. We then ask a range of questions on revenue use, predicted behavior change as well as the potential winners and losers of the policy, including in the urban and suburban context.

Design details

Randomization method
Random assignement to treatment group is done by the survey company.
Randomization unit
The display of the videos is randomized at individual level.
Clusters
4000 households, with 2000 each in the Berlin-Brandenburg and the Paris-Ile-de-France agglomeration.
Observations
4000 households, with 2000 each in the Berlin-Brandenburg and the Paris-Ile-de-France agglomeration.
Arms
We include 4000 households in our survey who are randomly split into four groups, i.e. 1000 per group.
Primary outcomes
Our primary outcome variable is support for an urban toll.
Secondary outcomes
We quantify heterogeneous treatment effects by including interactions between socioeconomic characteristics and treatment status. Two interesting candidates for interactions are whether the respondents reside within the city center or in suburban areas and to what extent they use the car for commuting.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords