The Role of Gender and Decision-Making Structure in Hiring Decisions
How to cite
Jain, Prachi; Miller, Michelle. 2023. "The Role of Gender and Decision-Making Structure in Hiring Decisions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010775. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10775-1.1
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
An abundance of statistics has shown the gender disparity in corporate organizations, political bodies, and university positions. These facts lead to a natural question: why aren’t women being hired or promoted in the workplace? This project examines the role decision-making bodies play in gender disparity in hiring using a laboratory experiment.
Our first research question asks: how does the gender composition of a hiring committee affect who gets hired? Additionally, the process by which hiring decisions are made likely plays an important role in affecting who gets hired. For example, are decisions made democratically with all members having an equal voice? Or are decisions made unilaterally by a leader? Therefore, our second research question asks: how does the decision-making structure of the hiring committee affect who gets hired?
Intervention
We will vary the gender composition of the three-person groups. Additionally, we will vary the decision-making structure of the group. Some groups will decide who to select to “hire” based on a majority vote. Some groups will decide who to select based on a unanimous vote. In some groups, a randomly selected leader from the group will select who to "hire”. In some groups, a volunteer leader from the group will select who to “hire”.
Experimental design
Subjects are given three resumes and must decide who to select to “hire”, both individually and in groups. Which resume is selected for “hire” determine the subjects’ payments; they receive higher payments if they select the resume corresponding to the higher ranked performer. Groups can interact using a chat interface to decide who to select. The three-person groups vary in gender composition and in how they make their decisions about who to select. Subjects participate in 6 or 8 rounds (with differing sets of resumes); groups vary between rounds.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.