The Impact of Experiential Learning Interventions on Sustainable Water Management: Evidence from a Randomized Control Trial in India

How to cite

Meinzen-Dick, Ruth; Falk, Thomas; Kosec, Katrina; Zhang, Wei; Melesse, Mequanint; Priyadarshini, Pratiti. 2023. "The Impact of Experiential Learning Interventions on Sustainable Water Management: Evidence from a Randomized Control Trial in India." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010765. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10765-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ruth Meinzen-Dick* , Thomas Falk , Katrina Kosec , Wei Zhang , Mequanint Melesse , Pratiti Priyadarshini

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010765
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10765-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-10-15 – 2023-12-31
Countries
India (Andhra Pradesh), India (Karnataka), India (Rajasthan)
JEL codes
Q01, Q15, Q25
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10765

Abstract

This study provides rigorous testing of the effectiveness of a package of experiential learning tools related to groundwater management in India on mental models, norms, and behavior. The experiential learning intervention includes three main tools: 1) collective action games that allow people to experience the effect of their water use decisions on water management and to try out different rules; 2) structured community debriefings to discuss the implications of the games; and 3) crop water budgeting to facilitate participatory water resource planning. We use a collective action groundwater game developed and piloted by the International Food Policy Research Institute (IFPRI) and Foundation for Ecological Security (FES), in which participants choose between crops with different water consumption levels and see the effects of their decisions on water tables over multiple rounds of play. To facilitate full participation of women and men, games take place in separate groups of women and of men. The intention of the games is to create awareness and receptivity to changing water management practices. We then follow game play with a debriefing discussion with the full community. Finally, we complement game play with provision of information about technical and institutional options for more sustainable water management. Specifically, we do so by engaging with the farmers to apply a Crop Water Budgeting tool, which supports community-level discussions for development of collective cropping patterns that save water.

The primary population of interest are farmers using groundwater in Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, and Rajasthan states in India, where overuse of groundwater has led to falling water tables. All districts also have hard rock (confined) aquifers, such that local water extraction—or refraining from extraction—can affect local water tables. Within each state, the key selection criterion was districts and communities where Foundation for Ecological Security (FES) has an active program in commons management for at least 10 years, so that there would be community resource persons (CRPs) who could be trained to implement the experiential learning tools.

We selected a total of 472 habitations (communities) where the interventions had not been used, stratified by the presence of surface irrigation, and randomly assigned 2/3 of the sample to treatment and 1/3 to control. To select individuals, focus group discussions (FGDs) were held all communities; among FGD members, 5 women and 5 men were randomly selected to play the game, and 3 men and 3 women randomly selected for an individual survey. In control communities, 3 men and 3 women were similarly selected for the survey; no games or debriefing took place. Baseline data collection and first round of interventions took place.

Baseline data collection was conducted over 3 months (November 15th 2021 – 7th March 2022). The intervention was repeated in September-December 2022, and endline data collection is planned to begin on January 17, 2023. Major data sources are baseline and endline key informant interviews and focus group discussions; an individual survey of game players and game data; community debriefing discussion; crop water budgeting data; and habitation records.

Intervention

Overextraction of groundwater has led to depletion of this vital resource in many areas in India. This study examines the effect of experiential learning tools related to groundwater management, including: 1) collective action games that allow people to experience the effect of their water use decisions on water management and to try out different rules; 2) structured community debriefings to discuss the implications of the games; and 3) crop water budgeting to facilitate participatory water resource planning. We examine the effects of the experiential learning package on mental models, norms, rules, and behavior.

Experimental design

This randomized control trial focuses on three states in India: Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka, and Rajasthan. These states were selected due to the severity of their water crises and their high dependence on groundwater. Within each state, the key selection criterion was districts where FES has an active program in commons management for at least 10 years, so that there would be community resource persons (CRPs) who could be trained to implement the experiential learning tools. All districts also have hard rock (confined) aquifers, such that local water extraction—or refraining from extraction—can affect local water tables.

We randomly sampled habitations into treatment and control groups using a stratified (by our six strata, defined by state and presence or lack of presence of surface irrigation infrastructure) randomization procedure designed to achieve two-thirds of the sample being assigned to treatment and one-third to control. In particular, we used the “randtreat” command in Stata, while indicating our use of these stratifying variables and our desire for a 2/3 – 1/3 ratio of treatment to control units.

Design details

Randomization method
For the randomization process, we randomly sampled habitations into treatment and control groups using a stratified (by our six strata, defined by state and presence or lack of presence of surface irrigation infrastructure) randomization procedure designed to achieve two-thirds of the sample being assigned to treatment and one-third to control. In particular, we used the “randtreat” command in Stata, while indicating our use of these stratifying variables and our desire for a 2/3 – 1/3 ratio of treatment to control units. Within each state – water infrastructure status (yes/no) combination (i.e., strata), non-sampled habitations were randomly ranked such that they could serve as possible replacements. As needs for replacement habitations emerged, the non-sampled habitation with the lowest rank within the same strata was used as a replacement and given the treatment status of the habitation it was replacing. Where no replacement habitations were available within the same strata, we took the lowest ranked replacement habitation that was from the same state. In this way, we identified 29 replacements.
Randomization unit
Habitation (community)
Clusters
472 habitations
Observations
2,360 individuals
Arms
158 habitations in the control group and 314 habitations in the treatment group
Primary outcomes
In this study we plan to work with three types of outcomes: 1) individual level outcomes; 2) group level outcomes; and 3) habitation level outcomes. For this, we will use information from five sources: a) Focus group discussion (FGD); b) Key informant interview (KII); c) Individual survey of game players; d) Crop Water Budgeting (CWB) report; and e) Habitation records. We propose nine hypotheses: 1. Hypothesis 1: Outcomes related to better system understanding (individual and group levels). 2. Hypothesis 2: Outcomes related to stronger norms for sustainable water management (individual and collective level). 3. Hypothesis 3: Outcomes related to women more involved in water-related decision-making (collective level). 4. Hypothesis 4: Outcomes related to water management rules (individual and collective levels). 5. Hypothesis 5: Outcomes related to better rule enforcement of water management rules (collective level). 6. Hypothesis 6: Outcomes related to more likely to invest in water harvesting structures or leverage public funds for the purpose (collective level). 7. Hypothesis 7: Outcome related to conditions of water-related infrastructure (collective level). 8. Hypothesis 8: Outcome related to crop choice with lower water consumption leading to irrigated water savings (collective level). 9. Hypothesis 9: Outcome related to depletion of water table (collective level).
Secondary outcomes
Hypothesis 1 We will examine the effect of the intervention on the individual variables iBenefitCoordination, iFamersInteract and iUseAffectsGW To the extent that there are differences between “agree” and “strongly agree in the individual varuables, we will complement our analysis with an ordered logit of these variables. All individual indicators mentioned in the primary outcome section will further be aggregated at the group level and condensed to an index by adding all three above, group-level outcome indicators. Hypothesis 2 We will examine the effect of the intervention on the individual variables iRulesGroundwater, iCooperateToInvest, iNoRulesGroundwaterOwnLand, iAllAccessSurface, iSupportGovtRules, iSupportGvtPolicy1, iSupportGvtPolicy2. For sensitivity analysis, we will also conduct a principal component using all individual indicators aggregated at the group level and compute an index. These would be mainly variables at the group level and some of them at the community level. Hypothesis 3 We will generate an indicator using individual variables aggregated at the group level and we will also use responses to questions in the Focus Group Discussions related to women’s involvement in decisions among the community. Hypothesis 4 We will examine the effect of the intervention on the individual variables used to compute the index. We will use the habitation records to complement our analysis and will create our second main community-level outcome for this hypothesis. Hypothesis 6 We will complement the analysis using individual contribution variables. Some of them add new dimensions and others can be used to cross check the information provided by key informants. We will also include community-level indicators created from the FGDs to complement our analysis. If habitation records indicate the amount of resources mobilized, this will be noted in discussion. Hypothesis 7 We also define community-level indicators using the Focus Group Discussion information to complement our analysis. Hypothesis 8 We will use crop choice data from the individual surveys to create additional variables and use community level crop choice data from key informant interviews to test this hypothesis.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords