Layoffs and the Survivor Syndrome – A Field Experiment

How to cite

Heinz, Matthias; Jeworrek, Sabrina; Martins, Vanessa; Schumacher, Heiner. 2016. "Layoffs and the Survivor Syndrome – A Field Experiment." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001075. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1075-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Matthias Heinz* , Sabrina Jeworrek , Vanessa Martins , Heiner Schumacher

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001075
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1075-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2016-02-22 – 2016-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1075

Abstract

While downsizing in firms may be necessary for growth in a dynamic economy, layoffs are often discussed controversially in the general public and in the media. A significant amount of psychological literature suggests that downsizing creates costs associated with a decrease in work morale and motivation of those who remain employed in the company. This phenomenon is called “survivor syndrome.” To analyze the survivor syndrome, we conduct a field experiment in which subjects work in a natural work environment, and in which layoffs can be implemented in randomized manner. Subjects perform a telephone survey at a call center, which we rent for several weeks. The main output variable is the number of calls made. Between our treatments we vary the information that we provide to the non-fired subjects about the layoffs of their co-workers. To study heterogeneity in subjects’ reactions to layoffs, the field experiment will be followed by an online experiment that produces a measure of subjects’ direct and indirect negative reciprocity.

Intervention

While downsizing in firms may be necessary for growth in a dynamic economy, layoffs are often discussed controversially in the general public and in the media. A significant amount of psychological literature suggests that downsizing creates costs associated with a decrease in work morale and motivation of those who remain employed in the company. This phenomenon is called “survivor syndrome.”

To analyze the survivor syndrome, we conduct a field experiment in which subjects work in a natural work environment, and in which layoffs can be implemented in randomized manner. Subjects perform a telephone survey at a call center, which we rent for several weeks. The main output variable is the number of calls made.

Each subject performs the telephone survey for two working days. On the second working day, randomly selected workers are “laid off”. Between our main and our control treatments we vary the information that we provide to the non-fired subjects about the layoffs of their co-workers. In our main treatment we inform them that their co-workers were fired; in our control treatment we will tell them that less workers are employed, without any reference to layoffs. In a third treatment no workers are “laid off”.

To study heterogeneity in subjects’ reactions to layoffs, the field experiment will be followed by an online experiment that produces a measure of subjects’ direct and indirect negative reciprocity.

Finally, we will call all subjects a few weeks after the online experiment and debrief them about their role in the field experiment. We also invite them to participate in a short phone survey. In the phone survey we will try to identify contamination between treatment and control groups and study how subjects interpreted the layoff situation.

Experimental design

While downsizing in firms may be necessary for growth in a dynamic economy, layoffs are often discussed controversially in the general public and in the media. A significant amount of psychological literature suggests that downsizing creates costs associated with a decrease in work morale and motivation of those who remain employed in the company. This phenomenon is called “survivor syndrome.” To analyze the survivor syndrome, we conduct a field experiment in which subjects work in a natural work environment, and in which layoffs can be implemented in randomized manner. Subjects perform a telephone survey at a call center, which we rent for several weeks. The main output variable is the number of calls made. Between our treatments we vary the information that we provide to the non-fired subjects about the layoffs of their co-workers. To study heterogeneity in subjects’ reactions to layoffs, the field experiment will be followed by an online experiment that produces a measure of subjects’ direct and indirect negative reciprocity.

Design details

Randomization method
coin flip
Randomization unit
Working shifts / days
Clusters
(2*) 15 working days
Observations
170
Arms
50 main treatment, 50 control treatment 1, 50 control treatment 2
Primary outcomes
Main outcome variable: Number of telephone calls Minor outcome variables: Qualitative phone data, qualitative data from a feedback survey after the second working day

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords