Evaluation of the Women’s Land Tenure Security and Green Subsidy Components of NBCA-CLUSA’s PROMAC II Program in Mozambique

How to cite

Brudevold-Newman, Andrew; Montalvao, Joao; Boxho, Claire; O'Sullivan, Michael. 2023. "Evaluation of the Women’s Land Tenure Security and Green Subsidy Components of NBCA-CLUSA’s PROMAC II Program in Mozambique." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010728. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10728-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Andrew Brudevold-Newman* , Joao Montalvao , Claire Boxho , Michael O'Sullivan

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010728
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10728-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2020-08-01 – 2023-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10728

Abstract

This impact evaluation will use a randomized controlled trial approach to measure the stand-alone and complimentary impacts of two components of an international NGO's agricultural program: land-use documentation and the distribution of long-term agricultural investment bundles. The land-use documentation component formalizes land-use rights though the formalized rights may not be sold or collateralized. The land-use titles are offered to households conditional on a woman’s name on the title (either co-titled or registering it exclusively under her name). This offer will include a discussion of the benefits of land titling and co-titling to encourage uptake. The long-term investment bundle offers women a package of fruit-tree seedlings together with pesticides, fungicide, and other inputs such as cassava, sweet potato, and pumpkin cuttings designed to help farmers in the shorter-term. This portion of the study centers on randomizing 1,000 eligible households (those who farm their own land but do not have land-use titles, and are either married or female) into one of three treatment groups or a control group: the first treatment group will receive land-use titles, the second treatment group will receive the input subsidies, and the third treatment group will receive both the land-use titles and the input subsidies.

In addition to measuring the impacts of these two components, the study will also use the distribution of the long-term investment bundles to measure the short-term impacts of the land-use title on willingness to invest in agricultural inputs. Specifically, the bundles will initially be distributed through a take-it-or-leave-it offer conducted under a willingness to pay experiment, presented to the household's head woman together with her husband, if married. After detailing the bundle, the representatives presented the women with an opportunity to commit to purchasing the bundle at one of six randomly selected subsidy levels: 96\%, 87\%, 79\%, 71\%, 63\%, and 54\%. The women were only presented with one of the prices and were told that they would not have another opportunity to purchase the bundle. After confirming that the respondents understood the offer and the market value of the bundle, the representatives presented the women with the final offer and recorded the purchase decision. This portion of the study will jointly examine the impacts of the land-use demarcation and subsidy offer on the likelihood of accepting the agricultural investment opportunity.

Intervention

This study focuses on two components of an international NGO's agricultural program: land-use documentation and the distribution of long-term agricultural investment bundles. The land-use documentation component formalizes land-use rights though the formalized rights may not be sold or collateralized. The land-use titles are offered to households conditional on a woman’s name on the title (either co-titled or registering it exclusively under her name). This offer will include a discussion of the benefits of land titling and co-titling to encourage uptake. The long-term investment bundle offers women a package of fruit-tree seedlings together with pesticides, fungicide, and other inputs such as cassava, sweet potato, and pumpkin cuttings designed to help farmers in the shorter-term.

Experimental design

The sample comprises 1,064 households participating in the international NGO's agricultural program in Molumbo district in Mozambique’s Zambezia Province. Eligibility is restricted to those who farm their own land but do not have land-use titles, and are either married or female. The evaluation is structured around a single-stage randomization where eligible households are randomized into one of three treatment groups or a control group: the first treatment group will receive land-use titles, the second treatment group will receive the input subsidies, and the third treatment group will receive both the land-use titles and the input subsidies. Farmers will be stratified by lead farmer and gender.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Individual randomization stratified by lead farmer and gender. Additionally, under the willingness to pay experiment, individuals assigned to receive the input bundle will be further randomized to receive one of five prices. This randomization will be done within the existing strata.
Clusters
1,064 households
Observations
1,064 households
Arms
266 households control, 266 households receiving the land use titles only, 266 households receiving the input bundle only, and 266 households receiving both land use titles and the input bundle.
Primary outcomes
Perceived land tenure security including ownership, management, and transfer rights Uptake of new agricultural technologies and practices with a focus on climate smart agriculture Agricultural outcomes: production, value of harvest sold, land holdings, land cultivated - overall and by crop Household income: total household income, total farm income, total non-farm income, assets, consumption Agricultural inputs including individual, household, and hired labor Off-farm activities including non-farm labor supply and incomes

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords