Organizational Dynamics and Administrative Data Production
How to cite
Slough, Tara. 2023. "Organizational Dynamics and Administrative Data Production." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010720. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10720-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
I study organizational dynamics in bureaucracies associated with the decentralized collection of administrative data. By decentralized data collection, I refer to state data that is solicited from decentralized governments by a central government agency. In collaboration with a national government organization in Colombia, I study organizational dynamics associated with the collection, reporting, and use of data within both decentralized governments and the partner agency itself. I study reporting behavior by bureaucrats in decentralized governments experimentally by embedding an RCT in a nation-wide administrative data collection effort. I the use of data by bureaucrats in the central government (partner) agency using qualitative methods.
Intervention
The experimental interventions are embedded in a new data collection effort by a Colombian government agency. To understand how communication within local bureaucracies influences administrative data submission, we use an encouragement design to increase the level of communication or communication between bureaucrats and politicians or other bureaucrats in their local government when collecting data for submission to the national government agency. Municipal governments assigned to treatment receive communication promoting this type of collaboration or communication. Those assigned to control do not receive this encouragement. To measure bureaucratic uncertainty, we use a within-subjects randomized elicitation of uncertainty.
Experimental design
The primary experimental manipulation utilizes an encouragement RCT design. In this design, municipal governments are randomly assigned to a treatment or control condition. The treatment encourages bureaucrats to consult with other individuals in their local government—whether other bureaucrats or the elected mayor—or others in their municipality. I contrast this to a control condition in which bureaucrats are simply asked to prepare responses. In the data collection, enumerators measured levels of collaboration or communication within the institution (the endogenous treatment). In the first stage, this design identifies the effect of the encouragement on levels of collaboration within local governments. I then can use this experimental manipulation to identify the ITT of encouragement or the complier average causal effect (CACE or LATE) of collaboration on attributes of the data submitted to the national government. Additionally, the design permits identification of quantile treatment effects, which measure the effects of encouragement on the distribution of responses.
The secondary experimental manipulation provides novel measurement of bureaucratic uncertainty. This within-subjects design elicits respondents' level of certainty three times, once per each block of two questions. In each block, of two questions, a municipal government is randomly assigned to provide their level of certainty on the first or second question. This design allows for measurement of uncertainty as well as studying the effects of certainty elicitation on subsequent responses. For the latter, this design facilitates the identification the ATE (and quantile treatment effects) of certainty elicitation on subsequent responses.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.