Social Preferences of Different Income Groups

How to cite

Maltz, Amnon; Ofek-Shanny, Yuval; Cohen, Rachelle. 2023. "Social Preferences of Different Income Groups." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010711. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10711-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Amnon Maltz* , Yuval Ofek-Shanny , Rachelle Cohen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010711
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10711-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-03-09 – 2023-05-31
Countries
Israel ()
JEL codes
D63 Equity, Justice, Inequality, and Other Normative Criteria and Measurement
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10711

Abstract

This study deals with fairness views of different income groups towards different types of inequality. Recent work has concentrated on views regarding inequality that is generated by luck and merit. In this work, we add to this literature and examine fairness views towards inequality that is based on someone else's taste (which we dub taste-based inequality). In an earlier study, we already examined this type of inequality alongside luck- and merit-based inequality on a representative sample of the adult Israeli population (the pre-registration of that study is available on the AEA RCT registry with RCT ID: AEARCTR-0008171).

In that study we reported suggestive evidence according to which people with below-average income treat taste-based inequality differently than people with above-average income. Moreover, it seems that the former group treat this source of inequality in a similar fashion to their treatment of luck while the latter treat it similarly to merit.

Since the previous study was not meant to examine this type of heterogeneity, the results regarding the behavior of the two income groups were underpowered in that study. For this study, we make a power calculation based on the results from that study in order to directly investigate the earlier suggestive findings.

We will run an incentivized online experiment based on the impartial spectator design (as in Almas et al., 2020). Roughly 3000 individuals take part in the experiment, out of which roughly 1140 will play the role of impartial spectators who will make redistribution decisions between two individuals with unequal earnings (570 spectators will belong to the below-average income group and 570 spectators will belong to the above-average income group). There will be three treatments corresponding to three different sources of inequality: Luck, Merit and Taste. Impartial spectators will be randomly selected into one of the three treatments.

Experimental design

The basic experimental design is similar to the one that appeared in our earlier experiment that studied social preferences over taste-based inequality (the pre-registration is on the AEA RCT registry with RCT ID: AEARCTR-0008171). There are only a few notable differences compared to the previous design. As a result, some chunks of the experimental design described below are taken from the pre-registration of the earlier study.

The general design is as follows:

Following the impartial spectator design in Almas et al. (2020), we will conduct an online experiment in order to capture the social preferences in the Israeli population. The experiment will be run by a panel company and will include roughly 3000 participants. The participants in the final stage of the experiment (the spectators) will be roughly 570 individuals with income that is above average and 570 individuals with an income that is below average (the income classification is based on self-reports of the panelists that are collected and updated regularly by the panel company). All participants will receive a participation fee. Some participants will receive an additional payment according to their performance, luck and decisions made by other participants in the study.

The study consists of three treatments: Luck, Merit and Taste. Using the impartial spectator design (Almas et al., 2020), spectators will be asked to redistribute payments between two other participants in the experiment who are randomly paired together. In each pair, one participant will have 12 ILS and the other will have nothing. The spectator will decide how to redistribute the money in the pair. The difference between treatments lies in the source of the initial inequality. In the first treatment the source will be luck. In the second treatment, it will be merit, i.e., the relative performance level in a task. Finally, in the Taste treatment, the source will be a decision of another participant who earned the money and chose to whom to transfer it based on some personal information provided by the pair.

Design details

Randomization method
All randomizations will be made using a computer program.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
No clusters planned.
Observations
The number of observations that will be relevant to the data analysis is roughly 1140 (roughly 380 spectators in each treatment). Half of them will be of below-average income and half will be of above-average income.
Arms
We have 4 types of participants: Participants in the first stage of the Taste treatment - 760 Benefactors in the second stage of the Taste treatment - 380 Workers (first stage of Luck and Merit treatments) - 760 Spectators (380 for each treatment) - 1140 Total - 3040
Primary outcomes
Implemented inequality by impartial spectators.
Secondary outcomes
Distribution of types of fairness views.

Materials

Papers from this trial

  1. Cohen, R., Maltz, A. and Ofek-Shanny, Y. (2025), Social Preferences Over Taste-Based Inequality. International Economic Review. https://doi.org/10.1111/iere.12770 https://doi.org/10.1111/iere.12770

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords