Mind the gap. Who evades VAT and by how much?
How to cite
Rostam-Afschar, Davud; Gaul, Johannes; Dörrenberg, Philipp; Voget, Johannes. 2023. "Mind the gap. Who evades VAT and by how much?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010699. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10699-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
VAT tax evasion erodes government budgets available for public goods, is a source of unfair competition, and exposes individuals to exploitative work conditions. The prevalence of VAT evasion and its determinants are difficult to study, because of its illegal nature. Our objective in this study is to identify the share of firms in Germany that have ever evaded VAT tax. We implement the randomized response technique in a sample of firm decision makers active in Germany. Additional information on the position in the value chain and the firm's industry allows us to compare the occurrence of VAT evasion across parts of the firm population that differ in their firm characteristics and scope of activity. We supplement the results on the prevalence of tax evasion with estimates of its quantitative importance using the indirect questioning technique. The results will provide important insights into the mechanics of tax evasion and valuable starting points for a refined discussion of policy measures to combat this phenomenon.
Experimental design
The experiment is designed as a combination of a between and within subjects treatment.
The randomization assigns 12.5% of respondents to a control group, that forces a response. 1-2(1/2)^4=87.5% of respondents may answer truthfully.
The between subjects component compares the proportion of respondents that indicate having evaded VAT beyond the control group. That is, the causal effect is the difference between the number of respondents who answer yes in the control treatment arm compared to the number of respondents who answer yes in the free responses treatment arm. The treatment works via the anonymity given by the randomization device. This effectively blinds the treatment allocations to avoid underreporting bias. A well-blinded RCT is considered the gold standard for clinical trials but is less known in economic applications.
The within subjects component then investigates how those who answered with yes in the first question respond to a subsequent question that uses the indirect questioning technique. The indirect questioning technique asks about the behavior of a competitor.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.