Promoting investment in solar energy across SMEs in Pakistan: the role of information provision

How to cite

Chaudhry, Theresa; Grabher-Meyer, Nikita; Chaudhry, Azam; Garner, Philip. 2022. "Promoting investment in solar energy across SMEs in Pakistan: the role of information provision." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010691. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10691-4.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Theresa Chaudhry* , Nikita Grabher-Meyer , Azam Chaudhry , Philip Garner

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010691
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10691-4.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2025-01-27 – 2026-08-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10691

Abstract

South Asia is one of the most vulnerable regions to climate change impacts but also one with vast untapped renewable energy potential (World Bank, 2021). Pakistan, for example, is endowed with huge solar energy resources and utilizing just 0.071% of the country’s area for solar photovoltaic installations would meet its current electricity needs (World Bank, 2021). The transition to renewables would help the country not only fulfil its growing energy demand and curb its carbon emissions, but also mitigate the high cost and unreliability of electricity from the grid, which is almost universally cited by local firms as a major constraint to competitiveness (Bacon, 2019). While larger exporting firms have begun to adopt solar energy also to comply with the environmental standards imposed by their globally branded customers, the more neglected market segment of small-medium enterprises is falling behind, according to a local source active in the solar market.
In this exploratory study, we intend to design and administer a survey across a sample of about 400 owners of small-medium manufacturing enterprises in central Punjab to better understand the main structural, informational and behavioural barriers that prevent business owners from switching to greener energy sources such as solar power. In particular, we will elicit respondents’ personal preferences, beliefs and attitudes around solar energy sources, as well as their intended behaviour or expected likelihood of adopting solar energy. In addition, we aim to conduct a randomized information experiment, embedded within the same survey, to test whether specific information provision is effective at changing respondents’ beliefs, attitudes and intentions in relation to purchasing solar energy.

Intervention

Our study aims to empirically test whether providing targeted information aligned with two of the three key belief categories of Ajzen’s Theory of Planned Behavior (1991) – precisely, attitudes toward solar adoption and perceived behavioral control – effectively changes respondents’ beliefs and purchasing intentions. This information will be communicated peer-to-peer as a short video featuring the narrative of a local factory owner who has successfully transitioned to a solar energy system. The video will break down the calculations and explain the installation and maintenance costs, savings, roof space requirements, financing options, and the ability to integrate solar with existing energy sources.

After asking a first battery of socio-demographic and standard firm characteristics as well as eliciting respondents’ prior beliefs and intention to adopt solar energy before the information provision, we will randomly assign respondents into three non-overlapping arms. Respondents will be randomly assigned either to a control group or to one of two information treatments (peer videos) targeting specific belief categories deemed the most relevant predictors of intentions and behavior about purchasing solar energy.

Experimental design

In Part 1, we will elicit respondents’ beliefs and attitudes around solar power and perceived behavioral control around solar installation. More specifically, following the best practice guidance provided by Fuster and Zafar (2021) and Haaland et al. (2021), the subjective beliefs that we would solicit from firm decision-makers would include the following, which will be elicit pre- and post-treatment:
- Respondents’ expected time frame for investing in solar energy
- Respondents’ overall feelings toward solar energy
- Respondents’ perceptions of the usefulness of solar in case only partial energy requirements are covered
- Respondents’ knowledge about the initial cost of solar energy
- Respondents’ perception about the ease of technical integration of solar systems with grid electricity and generator usage
- Respondents’ concerns about having sufficient roof/land space
- Respondents’ comfort regarding the installation/maintenance costs
- Respondents’ comfort regarding the ability to finance
- Respondents’ comfort with the affordability of monthly payments

We will also elicit personal preferences (including risk preferences and loss aversion measures), related expectations (macro expectations and expected electricity price increases), and control variables (current energy usage).

In Part 2, respondents randomly assigned either to a control group or to one of two information treatments will watch a short video. For the two treatments, the targeted information will be communicated peer-to-peer, featuring the narrative of a local factory owner who has successfully transitioned to a solar energy system. The treatment videos will break down the calculations and explain the installation and maintenance costs, savings, roof space requirements, financing options, and the ability to integrate solar with existing energy sources. The control video will feature the narrative of a local food processing factory owner who has successfully navigated the Covid period. The video also discusses industry trends in product and process innovation.

In Part 3, we will re-elicit respondents’ beliefs and attitudes around solar energy and the intended likelihood of purchasing it. We will ask for some additional beliefs post-treatment that we did not ask for pre-treatment. These are:

- Respondents’ intention to make an inquiry from a solar installation firm within the next 6 months
- Respondents’ access to further information about solar energy via a QR code provided at the end of the survey.
- Respondents' knowledge about solar energy usage by other firms in the same sector;
- Respondents’ knowledge about the impact of a solar energy investment on an average firm’s electricity bill savings (q. F1)
- Respondents’ perception about the future payback period (in years) until the investment in solar is recouped (q. G1)
- Respondents’ perception about the impact of solar investment on their customer base

In Part 4, we will ask a comprehensive battery of socio-demographic and standard firm characteristics. Based on the results of the analysis and on the available financial resources, we will try to investigate the longer-term impacts of information provision on beliefs, intentions, and actual purchasing behavior from the same respondents in a follow-up survey three to six months later.

The primary data collected through this survey tool will allow us to carry out two main types of analysis. First, we will be able to examine how respondents’ preferences, prior beliefs and attitudes over solar power affect the likelihood of investing in this renewable energy. We will look at how the relative contribution of structural and behavioral barriers in hindering the adoption of solar energy across small-medium enterprises in central Punjab changes across different sectors and generations. Second, our field experiment embedded in the survey will allow us to compare the average likelihood of purchasing solar energy across different treatment groups and test whether objective information provision is effective at changing attitudes towards solar energy and intentions to purchase it. Overall, by providing a better understanding of SME managers’ decision-making process, the study will help policymakers design more effective policy instruments to support the market deployment of renewable energies such as solar power.

Design details

Randomization method
By computer, the randtreat command in Stata.
Randomization unit
Firm
Clusters
We are aiming for 400 firms.
Observations
400 firms
Arms
We hope for a completed sample of 400 firms, with the following distribution: ~100 to 133 firms Treatment 1 ~100 to 133 firms Treatment 2 ~100 to 133 firms Control Group
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes (POs) we aim to influence through our information provision experiments are respondents’ intentions to adopt solar energy. These will be measured in some cases by questions asked pre- and post-intervention and in other cases by questions asked post-intervention only: 1. PO1: Respondents’ expected time frame for investing in solar energy 2. PO2: Respondents’ intention to make an inquiry from a solar installation firm within the next 6 months 3. PO3: Respondents’ access to further information about solar energy via a QR code provided at the end of the survey.
Secondary outcomes
Our secondary outcomes (SOs) represent the mechanisms driving potential changes in respondents’ intentions and will be measured by shifts in respondents’ beliefs about solar energy, as indicated by: 1. SO1: Respondents’ attitudes toward adopting solar i. Respondents’ overall feelings toward solar energy ii. Respondents’ perceptions of the usefulness of solar in case only partial energy requirements are covered iii. Respondents’ knowledge about the initial cost of solar energy iv. Respondents’ knowledge about the impact of a solar energy investment on an average firm’s electricity bill savings v. Respondents’ perception about the future payback period (in years) until the investment in solar is recouped vi. Respondents’ perception about the impact of solar investment on their customer base 2. SO2: Respondents’ perceived behavioral control. a) Non-financial aspects of behavioral control (SO2a) vii. Respondents’ perception about the ease of technical integration of solar systems with grid electricity and generator usage viii. Respondents’ concerns about having sufficient roof/land space b) Financial aspects of behavioral control (SO2b) ix. Respondents’ comfort regarding the installation/maintenance costs x. Respondents’ comfort regarding the ability to finance xi. Respondents’ comfort with the affordability of monthly payments xii. Respondents’ concern that investing in solar will limit their financial flexibility

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords