Female Participation in Male-Dominated Fields

How to cite

Pedote, Maria; Ferman, Bruno; Fontes, Luiz Felipe. 2022. "Female Participation in Male-Dominated Fields." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010671. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10671-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Maria Pedote* , Bruno Ferman , Luiz Felipe Fontes

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010671
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10671-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-07-01 – 2023-03-30
Countries
Brazil (Sao Paulo)
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10671

Abstract

Although female workforce participation has increased in the last decades, coding remains a male-dominated field. We have partnered with a coding course provider that is interested in increasing female enrollment and persistence throughout their selection process. One stage of the selection process, in particular, generates a significant gender imbalance: the need to play online logic and memory games. We designed a nudge experiment to try to enhance female take up of these games and their persistence through the selection process. The experiment will test whether providing information about female participation and performance in the previous selection process stimulates other women to persist in the process. Moreover, we would like to understand what are the potential barriers that discourage women to persist through the selection process and which are the mechanisms that can explain the effect (or lack of effect) of our proposed treatment. Thus, survey questions addressing beliefs will be inserted in the selection process. The results might shed light into how stereotypes and beliefs influence women's decision to enter and persist in male-dominated environments.

Intervention

To stimulate female (and also non-male) participation and persistence throughout the selection process, we will implement a nudge intervention. For candidates who enroll in the selection process but have not yet taken part in the second stage of the selection process - which consist of playing two online games (a logic and a memory one) - reminder messages about the importance of playing those games will be sent via WhatsApp. Candidates who are eligible to receive messages will be separated by gender and randomly selected into treatment and control group. Control candidates will receive a reminder message to play the games containing information about the coding course that is already available on the course’s website. Treatment group will receive the same message, but with one additional information: the fact that the coding course provider cares about gender diversity and half of the candidates admitted through the last selection process (which took place in July 2022) were non-male. Although we are primarily interested in the effect of treatment for women and other non-male candidates, treatment effect will be evaluated for all genders, separately.

Experimental design

The evaluation design will be based on the random allocation of a sample of enrolled candidates into one of the two conditions: (i) control ; (ii) treatment. Both conditions were described in the intervention. Randomization is within gender and within having answered the survey questions. Messages will be sent two or three times a week (when the database is updated), for candidates who (i) have enrolled since the last update, (ii) have not yet played the games, or have only played one of them and scored above the minimum level required to pass, and (iii) who have given consent to being contacted via WhatsApp. For candidates who receive the reminder messages but continue not to play the games, a reinforcement message will be sent about one week later (but not on the same weekday the the first message was sent).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
Approximately 1000 individuals: 700 men and 300 female or non-binary.
Observations
Approximately 1000 individuals: 700 male and 300 non-male (female or non-binary).
Arms
Approximately 500 control candidates: 150 non-male and 350 male. Approximately 500 treatment candidates: 150 non-male and 350 male.
Primary outcomes
Our outcomes of interest are: (i) whether the candidate plays the logic and memory games (each game will be analysed separately), up until two weeks after receiving the last reminder message, (ii) whether the candidate scores above 0 in the played game, (iii) the score attained (for those who play each game). Outcomes will be analyzed separately by gender.
Secondary outcomes
Mechanisms: answers to survey questions implemented during the registering stage of the selection process, measuring beliefs and previous coding knowledge. Secondary outcomes: participation on subsequent stages of the selection process and final approval into the coding course.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords