Increasing Adoption and Varietal Turnover of Seed: The Role of Consumer and Producer Side Interventions

How to cite

Campenhout, Bjorn Van; Nabwire, Leocardia; Trachtman, Carly; Kramer, Berber; Abate, Gahaw Tadesse; Colen, Liesbeth. 2022. "Increasing Adoption and Varietal Turnover of Seed: The Role of Consumer and Producer Side Interventions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010666. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10666-5.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Bjorn Van Campenhout* , Leocardia Nabwire , Carly Trachtman , Berber Kramer , Gahaw Tadesse Abate , Liesbeth Colen

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010666
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10666-5.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2023-02-15 – 2024-02-01
Countries
Uganda (Busoga)
JEL codes
Q16, H24, O33, D91
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10666

Abstract

To increase adoption of new agricultural technologies, both push (supply side) and pull (demand side) factors are important. As a push factor to increase adoption of a particular technology such as an improved seed variety, some level of initial subsidy is often offered. For instance, companies may offer free trial packs of new improved seed varieties; governments may offer subsidies to increase varietal turnover. However, it is also often argued that if something was subsidized (or even free), it may not be used for the intended purpose. In this paper, we first test the effectiveness of free trial packs by testing if farmers that receive a sample of a new improved seed variety are more likely to adopt it in the future than a control group of farmers who did not get a free sample. Furthermore we test whether farmers learn differently from seed that was obtained for free than if they had to pay a (small) price for it. This questions is investigated using BDM auction—essentially a two stage pricing design—such that we can disentangle the selection effect, whereby farmers that are prepared to pay a price are likely to be more motivated to learn from it for subsequent adoption decisions, and the sunk cost effect, where a product that has a price attached to it is valued more. In addition to the supply side intervention, we also test the relative effectiveness of a demand sided intervention for adoption of new or improved varieties—an area often overlooked in existing research. In particular, we cross-randomize an intervention where households are demonstrated how to prepare the new seed variety and get the ability to taste it.

Intervention

There will be two main treatments in this experiment, each corresponding to one of the two factors in the 2x2 factorial design (see experimental design below). For the first factor, the treatment level will consist of a seed trail pack that the household receives. This trial pack will be an improved seed variety (hybrid seed) that is available in the market but at the same time not yet widely adopted by farmers. The control level for this factor will simply be the absence of a seed trial pack, that is, these household will not receive a seed trial pack.
For the second factor, the treatment level consists of an event where farmers are shown how easy it is to prepare food grown with the improved variety and farmers are allowed to taste. Also here, control level for this factor will again be the absence of these events, that is, households in control villages will not be exposed to such events.
To investigate screening/sunk cost effects, we add a third interventions that involves a BDM auction for the seed trial packs (in a sense this can be seen as a subsidized seed trail pack treatment).

Experimental design

The study will use a clustered 2x2 factorial design. The clusters will be villages, in which a fixed number of households will be selected to participate in the study. To study screening and sunk cost effects, we confine ourselves to the treatment factor of the seed trial intervention (that is, half of the sample that is used to power the 2x2 factorial design). In this subset, we match to each treated household a household that will be offered seed at a non-zero transaction cost. While all households in the treatment factor of the seed pack intervention will be subjected to a BDM, we will make sure that half of these individuals will receive a 100 percent discount (that is, make sure that the price the computer draws is zero).

Design details

Randomization method
randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
villages
Clusters
27 clusters in each of the four treatment cells + 2 times 27 clusters for the sunk cost/selection effect experiment with the BDM.
Observations
3240 households
Arms
540 pure control households in 27 pure control villages, 540 free seed pack households in 27 free seed trial pack villages, 540 subsidized seed pack households in 27 subsidized seed trial pack villages, 540 consumption intervention households in 27 consumption intervention villages, 540 consumption intervention + free seed trail households in 27 consumption intervention + free seed trail villages, 540 consumption intervention + subsidized seed trail households in 27 consumption intervention + subsidized seed trail villages
Primary outcomes
seed used at endline
Secondary outcomes
production and consumption of improved seed varieties

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords