Testing what works to accelerate varietal turnover: An experiment in Kenya

How to cite

Kramer, Berber; Trachtman, Carly; Cecchi, Francesco; Waweru, Carol; Kivuva, Benjamin; Waithaka, Lilian. 2022. "Testing what works to accelerate varietal turnover: An experiment in Kenya." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010651. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10651-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Berber Kramer* , Carly Trachtman , Francesco Cecchi , Carol Waweru , Benjamin Kivuva , Lilian Waithaka

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010651
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10651-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-09-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Kenya (Western (Busia, Bungoma)), Kenya (Lower Eastern (Machakos, Makueni)), Kenya (Upper Eastern (Embu, Meru, Tharaka Nithi))
JEL codes
Q12, Q16, O33, D13, C93
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10651

Abstract

The turnover of improved crop varieties among smallholder farmers has been slow, and little is known about the drivers of varietal replacement and product substitution. Such low varietal turnover limits the extent to which investments in crop breeding programs can contribute to achieving the sustainable development goals. This cluster randomized trial, implemented in seven counties in Kenya, will therefore generate behavioral intelligence on what drives farmers', consumers' and private-sector decisions to adopt new varieties. Specifically, we will test whether varietal turnover can be accelerated through four interventions:
1) Providing trial packs of new varieties, to provide farmers with the opportunity to test new varieties at a lower cost (randomized at the village level, with additional randomization within villages in terms of who receives trial packs);
2) Providing personalized advisory services, to alleviate information constraints on how to cultivate these new varieties (randomized at the village level, with additional randomization within villages in terms of who is targeted with advisories);
3) Providing agricultural insurance subsidies, to reduce the financial risk associated with investing in more expensive seeds (randomized at the farmer level, within villages); and
4) Targeting the same set of farmers with a consumer-oriented intervention that addresses factors related to the taste, texture, nutritious value or other consumer-related characteristics of the final product associated with a new variety (randomized at the village level).

The trial is implemented in 160 villages spread across seven counties in Kenya, with 40 farmers per village recruited into the study. Results are expected to be available by December 2024.

Intervention

We will test whether the adoption of new varieties can be accelerated through four interventions:
1) Providing trial packs of new varieties, to provide farmers with the opportunity to test new varieties at a lower cost;
2) Providing personalized advisory services, to alleviate information constraints on how to cultivate these new varieties;
3) Providing agricultural insurance subsidies, to reduce the financial risk associated with investing in more expensive seeds; and
4) Targeting the same set of farmers with a consumer-oriented intervention that addresses factors related to the taste, texture, nutritious value or other consumer-related characteristics of the final product associated with a new variety.

Experimental design

We randomized, at the village level, and with stratification by county, whether farmers were offered trial packs of new varieties and whether they would receive personalized advisory services. Within each treatment arm, we will further randomize whether or not the consumer-oriented intervention is implemented.

Within each village, we recruited 40 farmers. All farmers are offered insurance, but at the farmer level, the insurance premium discount level is randomized into high (25% of the sample), low (25% of the sample) or no discount (50% of the sample within a village). We cross-randomize whether or not a farmer is provided with a trial pack; 20 farmers per trial pack village receive a trial pack.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Village level randomization for trial pack, personalized advisory services, and consumer-oriented intervention Individual randomization for insurance premium subsidies
Clusters
160 villages
Observations
6400 farmers (40 farmers per village)
Arms
1A. No trial packs, no personalized advisory services, no consumer intervention: 20 villages 1B. No trial packs, no personalized advisory services, consumer intervention: 20 villages 2A. No trial packs, personalized advisory services, no consumer intervention: 20 villages 2B. No trial packs, personalized advisory services, consumer intervention: 20 villages 3A. Trial packs, no personalized advisory services, no consumer intervention: 20 villages 3B. Trial packs, no personalized advisory services, consumer intervention: 20 villages 4A. Trial packs, personalized advisory services, no consumer intervention: 20 villages 4B. Trial packs, personalized advisory services, consumer intervention: 20 villages
Primary outcomes
Adoption of promoted varieties. Both aggregate and disaggregated by gender.
Secondary outcomes
Investments in seed, adoption of modern production technologies, investments in agriculture, agricultural productivity for target crops (yield per acre), total value of production, agricultural income. Both aggregate and disaggregated by gender.
Sponsors
Name: CGIAR Initiative on Market Intelligence Location: Global Url: https://www.cgiar.org/initiative/05-market-intelligence-for-more-equitable-and-impactful-genetic-innovation/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords