Access to Renewable Energy. Micro-Finance for Small Businesses and Micro Enterprises in Pakistan.

How to cite

Müller, David Frank; Avdeenko, Alexandra; Frölich, Markus. 2022. "Access to Renewable Energy. Micro-Finance for Small Businesses and Micro Enterprises in Pakistan.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010648. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10648-1.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

David Frank Müller* , Alexandra Avdeenko , Markus Frölich

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010648
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10648-1.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-09-01 – 2025-03-31
Countries
Pakistan (Punjab and Sindh)
JEL codes
O13, H23, G21, G22
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10648

Abstract

We study the uptake of solar panels financed through micro-loans by micro-enterprises and small businesses in rural Pakistan. Working with 1400 households, we test two interventions randomized at the household level: first, we provide households with a one-time subsidy payment at the beginning of the loan-period. Second, we provide an index-insurance throughout the loan repayment period that aims at insuring low returns of solar panels. Besides uptake behavior, we are testing the impacts of the two interventions on business profits, investments, and income variations over time. Individuals who meet the loan-eligibility criteria of the micro-finance institution and run a small business or enterprise are eligible for the treatments, which are assigned using a lottery for which the clients can apply.

Experimental design

The micro-finance provider that we are working with operates in rural Pakistan with several field offices. Each field office is responsible for the clients in a specific area. The randomized control trial will be conducted on two levels: first, we will randomly assign the 116 field offices to one of two possible intervention groups. Second, within field offices, clients can apply for a renewable energy loan and a lottery. In the lottery, clients can win a prize with 50% probability. In the first group of field offices, the prize that clients can win is the subsidy treatment conditional upon accepting the loan. In the second group of field offices, the prize that clients can win is the risk-coverage treatment (index insurance) conditional upon accepting the loan. Hence, we will have four types of clients (i.e., applicants) that we can compare: (1) 350 applicants that win a subsidy treatment in the first type of field-offices; (2) 350 applicants that have not won the subsidy treatment in the first type of field-offices but can still take up the loan without the subsidy; (3) 350 applicants that win a risk-coverage treatment in the second type of field-offices; (2) 350 applicants that have not won the risk-coverage treatment in the second type of field-offices, but can still take up the loan without the risk-coverage. Thus, we plan to operate with 1400 clients as a target sample.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization on both levels is conducted in office by a computer.
Randomization unit
First level of randomization is on the field-office level: field offices will be randomly divided in two groups. In the first group of field-offices, clients can win the subsidy treatment and in the second group of field-offices, clients can win the risk-coverage treatment. Within each field office, there is a randomization on the applicant level. Half of the applicants are randomly assigned to win the lottery and thus receive their respective treatment conditional upon accepting the loan.
Clusters
There are 116 field offices in the first step of randomization that can be considered as clusters; within clusters, treatment is randomly assigned among loan applicants.
Observations
1400 clients
Arms
In the first randomization step, the field offices are randomly split in two groups. (1) Hence, we have 58 field offices in which clients can win the risk-coverage treatment. Within these 58 field offices, we consider 700 applicants. Of those 700 applicants, 350 will be randomly assigned to win the lottery, i.e., to receive the risk-coverage treatment and another 350 will not win the lottery and will thus be considered as the control group. The 350 individuals in the control group can still take up the loan. (2) Moreover, we have another 58 field offices in which clients can win the subsidy treatment. Within these 58 field offices, we again consider 700 applicants. Of those 700 applicants, 350 will be randomly assigned to win the lottery, i.e., to receive the subsidy treatment and another 350 will not win the lottery and will thus be considered as the control group. The 350 individuals in the control group can still take up the loan.
Primary outcomes
Uptake of Solar panels
Secondary outcomes
1. Profits 2. Investments 3. Variations in income/profits 4. Electricity spendings/usage 5. Satisfaction with RE product 6. Awareness of climate change 7. Consumption

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords