A Dictator Game Experiment with the COVID-19 Vaccinated and Unvaccinated People: A Follow-up
How to cite
Sasaki, Shusaku; Kurokawa, Hirofumi. 2022. "A Dictator Game Experiment with the COVID-19 Vaccinated and Unvaccinated People: A Follow-up." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010611. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10611-1.2
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
In January-February 2022, we conducted financially incentivized dictator games with those with two COVID-19 vaccinations and those with zero vaccination in Japan (N=1,578), and ascertained their favorable or hostile attitudes toward each other, by using ingroup favoritism. We measured ingroup favoritism as the difference in the allocated amounts between to ingroup members with the same vaccination status and to outgroup members with a different status. Our analyses suggested that the vaccinated people behaved more discriminately toward outgroup members, compared to the unvaccinated people. The vaccinated people showed strong ingroup favoritism, which were shaped mainly by their outgroup bias of decreasing the money amount allocated to an unvaccinated pair, their outgroup member. In contrast, the unvaccinated people did not exhibit such the ingroup favoritism, on average. Their outgroup bias was found in the rather opposite direction of the hypothesis, and they tended to increase the amount to a vaccinated pair, their outgroup member. We found this tendency in particular from the unvaccinated who selected as their non-vaccination reason “I would like to get vaccinated if I could, but I cannot for health or other reasons.” Furthermore, we confirmed significant associations between their ingroup favoritism and attitudes regarding the COVID-19 policies, suggesting that the biases would have some degree of social influence in the real world.
In December 2022, we will conduct a follow-up experiment primarily on the above participants and examine how the ingroup favoritism, ingroup bias, and outgroup bias of vaccinated and unvaccinated participants change during the period from January-February to December, 2022. We will investigate whether the vaccinated people’s discrimination against the unvaccinated is temporary or persistent, from which we will derive policy implications.
Intervention
We conduct dictator game experiments in the following five conditions:
I. Anonymous: A recipient is anonymous for an allocator. The allocator is also anonymous for the recipient.
II. Current-Ingroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the current-ingroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who has received the three or more COVID-19 vaccinations up to December 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who has never received the COVID-19 vaccination as of December 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
III. Current-Outgroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the current-outgroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who has never received the COVID-19 vaccination as of December 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who has received the three or more COVID-19 vaccinations up to December 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
IV. Previous-Ingroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the previous-ingroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who received the two COVID-19 vaccinations as of January-February 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who did not receive any COVID-19 vaccination as of January-February 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
V. Previous-Outgroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the previous-outgroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who did not receive any COVID-19 vaccination as of January-February 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who received the two COVID-19 vaccinations as of January-February 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
Experimental design
We conduct dictator game experiments in the following five conditions:
I. Anonymous: A recipient is anonymous for an allocator. The allocator is also anonymous for the recipient.
II. Current-Ingroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the current-ingroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who has received the three or more COVID-19 vaccinations up to December 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who has never received the COVID-19 vaccination as of December 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
III. Current-Outgroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the current-outgroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who has never received the COVID-19 vaccination as of December 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who has received the three or more COVID-19 vaccinations up to December 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
IV. Previous-Ingroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the previous-ingroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who received the two COVID-19 vaccinations as of January-February 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who did not receive any COVID-19 vaccination as of January-February 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
V. Previous-Outgroup: An allocator is informed that a recipient belongs to the previous-outgroup (for the vaccinated sample, the recipient is an individual who did not receive any COVID-19 vaccination as of January-February 2022; for the unvaccinated sample, he/she is an individual who received the two COVID-19 vaccinations as of January-February 2022). The allocator is anonymous for the recipient.
One subject participates in five dictator game experiments as an allocator. We randomly set the order of the above conditions to create four groups in the vaccinated and unvaccinated samples, respectively. After we present the dictator game in the Anonymous condition (I) in all the four groups, we randomly present either of (II, III) or (III, II). We then randomly present either of (IV, V) or (V, IV). Consequently, each of the vaccinated and unvaccinated samples have four groups.
Furthermore, to address potential order effects caused by successive participation in the dictator games, we create a control group where we present the anonymous dictator game (I) five times. Totally, each of the vaccinated and unvaccinated samples have five groups, including the control group.
We explain more details in the attachment of the analysis plan.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.
Keywords
- behavior
- crime_violence_and_conflict
- governance
- health
- post-conflict
- COVID-19
- Vaccination behavior
- Vaccinated people
- Unvaccinated people
- Dictator game
- Ingroup favoritism
- Ingroup bias
- Outgroup bias
- cooperation
- Discrimination
- altruism
- reciprocity
- Public economics
- Health Economics
- Behavioral Economics
- Online laboratory experiment
- Japan