Employment and Irregular Migration: Evidence from Two Randomized Controlled Trials in Egypt

How to cite

Gazeaud, Jules; Fattah, Dina Abdel; Crepon, Bruno; Elsayed, Ahmed. 2022. "Employment and Irregular Migration: Evidence from Two Randomized Controlled Trials in Egypt." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010604. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10604-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Jules Gazeaud* , Dina Abdel Fattah , Bruno Crepon , Ahmed Elsayed

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010604
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10604-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2021-01-01 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Egypt ()
JEL codes
F22, O15
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10604

Abstract

Addressing the root causes of irregular migration has become a key policy priority in Europe. The EU Emergency Trust Fund for Africa (EUTF) was launched in 2015 with a budget of 5 billion euros to support projects aiming at deterring irregular migration flows from 26 origin countries. One of these projects is implemented by the Egyptian Micro, Small and Medium Enterprises Development Agency (MSMEDA) and targets unemployed youth in areas with the highest outflows of irregular migrants. We implement two randomized evaluations to assess whether (i) cash-for-work opportunities, and (ii) training and employment support have the intended effects on the direct beneficiaries and their relatives (household decision-maker, other household members, children, and friends). We assess impacts on people’s preferences and attitudes towards migration, irregular migration, as well as changes in their situation, aspirations, and expectations.

Intervention

We evaluate the effects of two interventions: (i) a cash-for-work intervention in which beneficiaries are paid to provide community services related to health, environment, adult literacy and nurseries, for an expected duration of 15 to 18 months on average; and (ii) a training and employment support intervention in which beneficiaries are provided with training packages and different services (financial services, job search aid, wage subsidies, etc.) designed to facilitate access to wage- and self-employment.

Both interventions are targeting unemployed youth (aged 18-29, in some cases up to 35) in the governorates with the highest outflows of irregular migrants (as identified by the Egyptian National Coordinating Committee for Preventing and Combating Illegal migration and human trafficking or NCCPIM-TIP).

While the cash-for-work intervention is focused on the rapid creation of temporary jobs for income, the training and employment support intervention aims to facilitate young people’s transition into more sustainable wage- and self-employment.

Both interventions are implemented as local sub-projects by NGOs. The training and employment support intervention also involves employers' federations and business associations.

The ex-ante theory of change is as follows:
- The interventions have a direct impact on participants by increasing their employment and employability. As a result, participants see that their current situation improves, and may also expect that their future situation will improve, which can in turn affect their intentions and attitudes toward migration. Effects on migration depend on whether participants are able to meet their aspirations locally, and how the interventions affect migration constraints. Participants will disregard migration – especially irregular migration – if they find (or do expect to find) opportunities that are in line with their aspirations and if the program does not relax migration constraints. In contrast, they will favor migration – especially irregular migration – if they do not find (or do not expect to find) opportunities that are in line with their aspirations or if the program relaxes migration constraints.
- The interventions also have an indirect effect on relatives: the household decision-maker, other household members, children, and friends. Different channels might be at play: (i) Intra-household dynamics: the participant's position in the household improves, and household decisions regarding the migration of other household members are now more in line with his/her preferences; (ii) Opportunity cost: the participant (or household decision-maker) decides there is no need to migrate because of improved living conditions; (iii) Financial constraints: the participant (or household decision-maker) uses his/her increased income to finance the migration costs of friends or other household members; (iv) Peer effects: the participant affects the perception of his/her relatives about what is possible to achieve locally which might in turn affect their migration outcomes.

In Egypt, women typically do not migrate to Europe irregularly, and migrate much less in general (e.g., to the Gulf or to urban areas). Women constitute about 80% of the sample in the cash-for-work intervention and 60% of the sample in the training and employment support intervention. To take this into account, we will present results separately for men and women. In addition, the focus should be different depending on the gender of the participant. For men, we are particularly interested in the direct effects of the program on their migration decisions and those of their peers (friends). For women, we are particularly interested in the indirect effects of the program on their relatives (children, household decision maker, and other household members).

Experimental design

Both evaluations rely on an over-subscription design. An individual can apply to only one of the interventions, and, after filling out a short questionnaire with the help of the local NGO (baseline data), she is randomized into treatment or control.

This study is registered in December 2022 (prior to the rollout of the first endline and to any analyses of a short midline survey conducted over the phone for individuals in the cash-for-work intervention).

Design details

Randomization method
Done in office by computer using STATA
Randomization unit
Individual level randomization
Clusters
Cash-for-work: 90 projects. Training and employment support: 34 projects. The actual number of projects might be smaller if projects get canceled.
Observations
Cash-for-work: 6,955 individuals at the time of registration. Training and employment support: 4,778 individuals at the time of registration. Follow-up data will be collected by a professional survey firm under the guidance of the research team. The actual number of observations will depend on the number of projects that get canceled and on our ability to track and find respondents included in the experiment. Because the baseline data are collected by local NGO implementing each project, with limited oversight from the research team (due to Covid and the large number of NGOs), we anticipate potential issues to track participants, especially for some projects. The actual number of observations might also be smaller in the case of fake/unknown applicants.
Arms
Cash-for-work: 4,270 Treatment, 2,685 Control. Training and employment support: 2,433 Treatment, 2,345 Control.
Primary outcomes
A. Migration intentions: intention to leave this place; intentions to migrate to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe, to Europe irregularly. B. Actual migration: migration to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe, to Europe irregularly. C. Irregular migration preparations and attempts: preparations to migrate irregularly to Europe; steps taken towards irregular migration to Europe; attempted to migrate irregularly to Europe.
Secondary outcomes
D. Migration likelihood and migration constraints: migration likelihood to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe; self-reported prevalence of eight migration constraints (lack of money, lack of information, lack of the required documents, lack of valuable skills, lack of contact at the destination, afraid to move, cannot take the risk, attachment to home, nothing). E. Labor force participation: employment; hours worked; earnings; occupation satisfaction; skill mismatch. F. Income aspirations in one year and in ten years. G. Expectations (expected probability of finding a job; expected earnings; expected life satisfaction) in the village, in Cairo/big city, in the Gulf, in Europe. H. Preferences regarding fertility and the migration of children and other household members (asked for different destinations: Cairo/big city, the Gulf, Europe, Europe irregularly). I. Migration of other household members: intentions to leave this place; intentions to migrate to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe, to Europe irregularly; preparations to migrate irregularly to Europe; actual migration to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe, to Europe irregularly. J. Household decision-maker’s preferences regarding fertility and migration to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe, to Europe irregularly. K. Friends’ intentions to migrate and actual migration to Cairo/big city, to the Gulf, to Europe, to Europe irregularly.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords