Patron-Dictator Game: Strategic Interaction between Charities and Donors

How to cite

Kato, Hiroki; Kim, Youngrok. 2022. "Patron-Dictator Game: Strategic Interaction between Charities and Donors." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010594. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10594-3.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Hiroki Kato* , Youngrok Kim

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010594
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10594-3.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-12-19 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10594

Abstract

In the charity market, donations are generally credence goods. In other words, in the charity market, there is an information asymmetry in that it is difficult for donors to know in advance the extent to which their donations improve recipients' welfare (charitable organizations retain this information). Thus, the dictator game, widely used to measure altruistic preference in laboratory experiments, may not correspond to real-world donation behavior because the recipient's welfare is visible.

This study makes a modified dictator game called the patron-dictator game that incorporates the role of charitable organizations. We conduct two games: the patron-dictator game and a standard dictator game in a lab experiment. Through these experiments, we examine two research questions: (1) the extent to which donation behavior in the Patron-Dictator game, which is similar to the real donation market, differs from that in the standard dictator game; (2) how donation information asymmetries affect donation behavior.

Intervention

The patron-dictator game consists of a patron, a dictator, and a receiver. In this game, the patron and dictator make decisions sequentially and determine the allocation of gains among the three players (see analysis plan for detailed game structure).

In addition to conducting the simple dictator game (the DG treatment), we create the following two interventions regarding the order of decision-making of the patron and dictator in the patron-dictator game:

1. First-Moving Dictator (FD): The dictator move first, followed by the patron.
2. Second-Moving Dictator (SD): The patron move first, followed by the dictator.

Experimental design

[Fixed] We schedule 9 sessions lasting 90 minutes per session over five days. We recruit up to 33 people per session (32 people per session with the DG treatment). In the beginning, participants take a quiz on the game structure (only FD and SD treatments). Next, they play a one-shot game repeatedly (10 rounds). We make at most 11 groups of three participants for the FD and SD treatments and up to 16 groups of two participants for the DG treatment. After each round, we randomly reassemble the groups and randomly change the roles. Finally, they take a survey of demographics and altruistic preferences.

Design details

Randomization method
[Fixed] We assign the DG treatment to the one session and the FD and SD treatments to the remaining 8 sessions. We equally randomize the two interventions at the session level to balance session dates and times.
Randomization unit
[Fixed] Experimental session.
Clusters
[Fixed] 9 experimental sessions.
Observations
[Fixed] up to 1,040 groups
Arms
[Fixed] 1. FD treatment: up to 440 groups (4 sessions) [Fixed] 2. SD treatment: up to 440 groups (4 sessions) [Fixed] 3. dictator game: up to 160 groups (1 sessions)
Primary outcomes
For consistency, we refer to the role of the dictator in the dictator game as a patron. Our primary outcome is amounts sent by a patron.
Secondary outcomes
1. Allocation of funds provided by patron between dictator and receiver in the FD and SD treatments 2. Receiver's gain

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords