Using experimental finance methodology, we simulate financial decision making under risk in the form of investment tasks. Experimental Currency Units aim to make the situation more realistic. The ECU frame, however, is often arbitrarily chosen. In particular, when tangibility or numerosity - individuals tend to over-infer quantity when it is represented with higher numeric values - has an effect on risk decision making. Do higher ECU frames bias decision making in financial risk-taking tasks? This study aims to test whether the ECU frame - affects financial decision making under risk. Our result will refine experimental finance methodology.
Intervention
We will recruit participants from Prolific. They will participate in an online experiment that collects all independent as well as the dependent measures, i.e. participants’ decisions in 5 experimental conditions (between-subjects design).
Experimental design
Design description
Participants will be recruited via Prolific. We may also recruit participants from Portsmouth University and Radboud University subject pools (except for members of the Faculty of Business and Law), or MTurk to verify the validity of our findings for different types of crowds. We will use the software Qualtrics to code the experiment.
Step 1: Presentation of consent form. Participants refusing to sign will stop the experiment at this stage, and be paid the show-up fee.
Step 2: Randomization into treatments (see treatments detail below) when sending the session link to participants. Each session corresponds to a treatment, following a between subject approach.
Step 3: General instructions and payment information. Details are given on experiments duration, payment procedures and anonymity.
Step 4: Control task to determine participants' risk perception.
Step 5: Treatment instructions. Participants are presented the instructions for the respective treatment that they were randomly allocated into. - Game 1: simple Investment game - Game 2: portfolio building game
Step 6: Demographic questionnaire
Design details
Randomization method
All participants take part in the same Qualtrics survey. The survey randomly allocates treatments to the participants keeping the observations per treatment at the same size.
Randomization unit
Individual.
Clusters
None.
Observations
500 participants in total.
Arms
100 participants per treatment.
Primary outcomes
1) Research question
How does the ECU framework affect risk taking in financial investment decisions?
With the ECU framework being defined as the exchange rate between Experimental Currency Units used during the experiment and actual currency used for payment.
2) Dependant variables
We first assess the participants' risk perception by presenting them a lottery and asking them to assess how risky they perceive this lottery with a Likert scale.
Then, in two investment tasks, the participants receive and ECU amount to invest.
In task 1, the participants receive an ECU endowment and invest five times in a simple two-outcome lottery (Gneezy and Potters, 1997). The dependent variable is the fraction invested - a measure of risk taking: f = Investment / Endowment. The higher the fraction invested, the higher the risk taken.
In task 2, the participants receive an ECU endowment and invest five times in a three lotteries portfolio decision. The dependent variables form different perspectives on the expected return (r) and the standard deviation (s) of the portfolio. On one hand we consider risk taking as measured by the sharp ratio and the standard deviation. On the other hand, we consider the deviation from the efficiency frontier.
3) Independent variables
Participants appointed to the following treatments receive the corresponding endowment:
o t0: 200 p (1 penny decision level)
o t1: 200 tokens (1 token decision level)
o t2: T1 x 10 = 2,000 tokens (10 token decision level)
o t3: T1 x 10^2 = 20,000 tokens (100 token decision level)
o t4: T1 x 10^3 = 200,000 tokens (1,000 token decision level)
4) Control variables
- Age
- Disposable income
- Gender
- Field of study
- Financial proficiency
5) Testable hypotheses
A) Tangibility: Participants have higher risk aversion with £ than with ECU, so they invest less in to than t1 (for both games).
B) Numerosity : Higher amounts increase numerosity which means that people become more uncertain dealing with higher amounts. Hence, we expect a reduction of participants' precision in all tasks (measured in standard deviation).
C) Non-constant relative risk aversion: Higher amounts induce participants to be more risk averse (Fehr-Duda et al., 2010). Hence, we expect a reduction in risk taking in all tasks when ECU frame increase.
D) Game-board effect: Extreme high amounts reduce understanding and value granted to ECUs by participants (Davis & Holt, 1993), we thus expect less risk aversion and higher standard deviation in the decisions they take.
Secondary outcomes
Following the literature, we expect:
- Risk aversion to be higher for female participants (Borghans et al., 2009),
- Risk aversion to increase with participants’ age (Albert & Duffy, 2012),
- Risk aversion to increase with disposable income (Hartog et al., 2002),
- Country of birth: we expect subjects from countries with more individualistic cultures to be more risk averse (Rieger et al., 2015),
- Variance to increase for non-native English speakers (as understanding of the instructions may decrease),
- Variance to increase for people studying non-economic topics.
Sponsors
Name: University of Portsmouth
Location: Portsmouth (UK)
Url: https://www.port.ac.uk/
Name: Radboud University
Location: Nijmegen (NL)
Url: https://www.ru.nl/en