Biased Beliefs, Motivated Reasoning, and Consumer Valuation of Vegetable Labels in Vietnam
How to cite
Kiesel, Kristin; Kiely, Sean; Rink, Ute; Mai, Ha Thi Vo. 2022. "Biased Beliefs, Motivated Reasoning, and Consumer Valuation of Vegetable Labels in Vietnam." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010541. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10541-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
This study uses a lab-in-the-field design to assess the belief updating process for consumers when presented with varying labeling schemes that communicate food safety information in retail markets for vegetables. Vietnam offers a unique setting to evaluate how individuals update beliefs over time through consumer internalization of labeling information for several reasons. First, consumers may have had emotionally intense prior experiences that make them more likely to form biased beliefs about the overall quality of vegetables in retail markets. They might have become ill from consuming vegetables with high levels of pesticide residue or vegetables that were otherwise contaminated. Households exposed to herbicides and defoliants during the Vietnam War might also be particularly concerned about pesticide use and have biased perceptions of food safety quality in retail markets. Second, relatively few labels currently exist to signal credence qualities in Vietnam’s retail market. Three labeling schemes are of interest to this study: 1) no labels are available to signal differences in quality or food safety, 2) vegetables are differentiated by a ‘pesticide-free’ voluntary private label, and 3) vegetables are differentiated by the VietGAP certified label.
Intervention
The study will be conducted over two waves spanning a total of two months. The first wave will include the experiment and survey questions. The choice experiment will endow participants with money and ask participants to: play a dictator game between themselves and a charity; to rank, rate, and state their willingness-to-pay (WTP) for vegetables prior to and after introduction of a food safety label (and accompanying definitions if appropriate; and to share their beliefs about the relative food safety of the vegetable options). Survey questions will assess: purchasing habits, food safety and food safety label knowledge, prior illnesses from vegetables, demographics, and exposure to chemical defoliants. The follow-up survey, conducted approximately one month later, will ask participants to recall what labels they saw during the experiment, the ranking they assigned to the vegetables after seeing the labels, and again, their willingness to pay. Participants will be properly incentivized to accurately recall their rankings but will also be given the option to state that they do not recall. This allows for individuals who engage in motivated reasoning to suppress their post-signal ranking at a personal financial cost.
Experimental design
This study will be conducted in Hue City, Vietnam. This city lies in Thua Thien Hue province, one of the most heavily sprayed areas during the Vietnam War, just south of the 17th parallel. We have partnered with the Center for Knowledge Co-creation and Development Research (CKC), a non-profit that is established in Hue which has experience administering and collecting survey data in the province. The head-of-household or primary shopper for the household will be asked to participate in the experiment.
The study targets both households directly affected and unaffected by Agent Orange. Households affected by Agent Orange will be included in the pool of households that will be randomly determined to participate in the study. The total sample size is expected to be 600 households split into two treatment and control groups. The treatment and control groups are not expected to differ from one another across any observable characteristics.
Households are assigned to two control groups and two treatment groups in this experiment. A vegetable label will be displayed to the control groups while the vegetable label and definition will be displayed to the treatment groups. The definition reduces uncertainty of the quality of the labeled good. The first control group is presented with one conventional vegetable and one pesticide-free vegetable (a 'pesticide-free' label that only addresses one dimension of food safety) without a definition of the label. While the first treatment group is presented with one conventional vegetable and one pesticide-free vegetable with the label and exact definition. Similarly, the second control group is presented with one conventional vegetable and one VietGAP vegetable without a definition and the second treatment group is provided with a conventional vegetable and a VietGAP vegetable with the label and exact definition. These labels and definitions are signals that provide the individual with additional information on the food safety quality of the good. The use of the two different labels and their definitions creates variation in the comprehensiveness and accessibility of the information presented.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.