Impact of a Randomized Controlled Trial in Arsenic Risk Communication on Household Water-Source Choices in Bangladesh
How to cite
Tarozzi, Alessandro; Geen, Alexander van; Ahmed, Kazi Matin; Balasubramanya, Soumya; Pfaff, Alexander; Bennear, Lori. 2016. "Impact of a Randomized Controlled Trial in Arsenic Risk Communication on Household Water-Source Choices in Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001052. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1052-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
We conducted a randomized controlled trial in rural Bangladesh to examine how household drinking-water choices were affected by two different messages about risk from naturally occurring groundwater arsenic. Households in both randomized treatment arms were informed about the arsenic level in their well and whether that level was above or below the Bangladesh standard for arsenic. Households in one group of villages were encouraged to seek water from wells below the national standard. Households in the second group of villages received additional information explaining that lower-arsenic well water is always safer and these households were encouraged to seek water from wells with lower levels of arsenic, irrespective of the national standard. A simple model of household drinking-water choice indicates that the effect of the emphasis message is theoretically ambiguous. Empirically, we find that the richer message had a negative, but insignificant, effect on well-switching rates, but the estimates are sufficiently precise that we can rule out large positive effects. The main policy implication of this finding is that a one-time oral message conveying richer information on arsenic risks, while inexpensive and easily scalable, is unlikely to be successful in reducing exposure relative to the status-quo policy.
Intervention
Samples households are given two types of oral communication regarding the arsenic contamination of the tube-well from which they collect drinking water. The first one is the comparison “status quo” communication and simply states that wells marked green are safe and below the government safety level of 50 ppb and those marked red are above the 50 ppb and unsafe. The treatment group known as the “emphasis” communication states that at any level of arsenic contamination, it is safer to switch to a source that has a lower level of arsenic.
Baseline survey was conducted with the female head of household. Follow-up surveys tracked whether the household switched drinking water source, physically visited the new source if a switch was made, and noted the level of arsenic in the new source.
Experimental design
In 2003, a local Bangladeshi organization BAMWSP tested tube-wells across Araihazar and labelled green those wells that had an arsenic level below 50 ppb and red those were above 50 ppb. By virtue of an earlier study done in 2005 by the Columbia University Superfund Basic Research Team, many wells were retested. In 2008, wells in 43 sample villages in Araihazar, which were tested in 2005, were labelled with an anodized aluminum plate showing a hand holding a drinking cup that is covered by a large cross when the arsenic level is above 50 micrograms per liter. It also indicates the year when the water sample was collected and the specific arsenic concentration detected in the water tested from that well.
Villages were randomly assigned to receive one of two information treatments. The first one is the comparison “status quo” communication and simply states that wells marked green are safe and below the government safety level of 50 ppb and those marked red are above the 50 ppb and unsafe. The treatment group known as the “emphasis” communication states that at any level of arsenic contamination, it is safer to switch to a source that has a lower level of arsenic. Thus even if the level is 40 ppb, it is safer to switch to one that is, for example, 10 ppb. Likewise if the only viable options are above the 50 ppb level, it is nonetheless better to switch from a 200 ppb to a 100 ppb. The communication is delivered only once for both groups.
Baseline survey was conducted with the female head of household. Follow-up surveys tracked whether the household switched drinking water source, physically visited the new source if a switch was made, and noted the level of arsenic in the new source.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.