Effects of a role model intervention on students’ aspirations, motivation and education choices

How to cite

Vadle, Zsuzsanna; Hajdu, Gergely; Haeckl, Simone. 2022. "Effects of a role model intervention on students’ aspirations, motivation and education choices." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010497. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10497-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Zsuzsanna Vadle* , Gergely Hajdu , Simone Haeckl

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010497
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10497-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-11-28 – 2025-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10497

Abstract

The project aims at investigating the effect of a role model intervention on students' educational and career aspirations and choices. We focus on schools located in the rural are of Hungary. Students of these schools have a higher probability of being “Not in Education, Employment, or Training” after leaving school than students in the urban area. Potential reasons for the insufficient educational attainment are unrealistic expectations about the costs and benefits of education, insufficient information about potential educational paths, low self-confidence, and a lack of role models whose path students could follow. Our project provides these role models by organizing classroom visits of volunteers who share their careers and educational journey.

Intervention

The experiment targets Hungarian high schools with a large proportion of disadvantaged students. The intervention is a presentation given by a role model for 30 minutes. Role models visit the schools at the same time and give a presentation during class time.

CHANGE: The intervention initially consisted of two 15-15 minutes presentations given by a female and a male role model but we changed the intervention to a 30 minutes presentation given by one role model.

Experimental design

In Period 1 (November - February), participating classes will receive an online survey that measures the outcome variables of interest at baseline as well as a set of control variables. Then individuals are randomized into treatment and control groups. We randomize individuals within classrooms. In Period 2 (two weeks later), the role models visit the school and give a presentation to the treatment groups, whereas the control group gets a test about their interests (based on Holland, 1985). Students within one class will be guided into two different rooms: the “role-model room” and the “aptitude room” (those names will not be used in front of the students). Students in the “role-model room” see a 30 minutes presentation given by a role model. During the same time, students in the “aptitude-test room” fill out the test about their interests. Immediately after the intervention, the students in both groups are asked to fill out a survey in which we measure their locus of control, belongingness, optimism, aspirations and expectations. We also measure students' interest in higher education by providing them with information material that they can download. We will record whether or not a student has clicked on the information link. In addition, students in the treatment group report how relatable the role model was. In Period 3 (end of the school year), we distribute a follow-up survey with the same questions as in Period 1. We also ask students to report whether they took the A-levels and whether they submitted their university applications. We will collect these data from the schools as well.

CHANGE: The intervention initially consisted of two 15-15 minutes presentations given by a female and a male role model but we changed the intervention to a 30 minutes presentation given by one role model.

Design details

Randomization method
It is a multi-site randomized trial with individual-level randomization. The sites are high-school classes in grades 11 and 12. Students draw a token that determines whether they go to the treatment or the control room.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
See planned number of observations
Observations
We randomize individuals within classes (individual blocked randomization) in the academic year 2022/23. The expected average number of students present in class (accounting for children being absent) is 24. As the sign-up is still in progress, we calculate the sample size under different scenarios. In scenario 1, we include classes of schools we have been in contact with and who said that they would like to participate in the study. In this scenario, we will be able to conduct the experiment in 23 classes, leading to a total sample of 552 students. In scenario 2, we only include classes, we will certainly be able to visit. This reduces our sample to 8 classes, leading to a total sample of 192 students. We hope to be able to come back to the schools that participate in this academic year in 2023/24 and recruit the new 11th-graders. This would increase our sample size to 888 students in scenario 1 and to 288 students in scenario 2. We do not know yet if we will be allowed to visit the schools again.
Arms
Scenario 1 with only 1 year of data collection: 552 (276 treatment, 276 control) Scenario 2 with only 1 year of data collection: 192 (96 treatment, 96 control) Scenario 1 with 2 years of data collection: 888 (444 treatment, 444 control) Scenario 2 with 2 years of data collection: 288 (144 treatment, 144 control)
Primary outcomes
Short-term outcomes: Educational Aspirations Educational Expectations Interest in Higher Education Intermediate-term outcomes: GPA Diligence Interest in Education (survey) Intention to apply to University Long-term outcomes (if available): Final GPA GPA A-Levels Application to University
Secondary outcomes
Manipulation checks: Locus of control Belongingness Perceived Importance of Education Optimism

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords