Targeting through Social Norms: Experimental Evidence from India's #GiveItUp Campaign
How to cite
Barnwal, Prabhat; Ryan, Nicholas. 2018. "Targeting through Social Norms: Experimental Evidence from India's #GiveItUp Campaign." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001048. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1048-2.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Social norms about who is deserving may help target public benefits, by making sure people in need receive benefits or by excluding people with lesser need to reduce program costs. The Government of India launched a campaign to use norms to improve the targeting of a cooking gas subsidy used by 220 million beneficiary households. The campaign, called Give It Up, asks beneficiary households to voluntarily forfeit cooking gas subsidies so the money can be used to subsidize the poor instead. We propose a field experiment to test the efficacy of self-targeting as a policy instrument and to measure whether the campaign induces spillovers in giving across households. The main policy outcome, usage of the cooking gas subsidy, is measured with high-quality administrative data in a sample of 1.2 million gas-using households. The cluster-randomized design will provide the first experimental estimates of the strength of spillover effects in charitable giving.
Intervention
Treated households are sent a mail package which consists of a letter requesting them to enroll in an ongoing charitable giving campaign to donate their fuel subsidy. Each mail package also includes an enrollment form and provides details on how to enroll online or via text message. Additionally, a sticker is included in the mail to a sub-sample of recipients, which can be used by the recipient to indicate that the recipient has enrolled. We further conduct an in-person charitable solicitation with a sub-sample of households.
Experimental design
We use a randomization design which includes cluster-level assignment of treatment saturation and individual-level assignment of treatment. Out of 1.2 million urban households in 3,802 clusters, 100,000 households are treated in a direct-marketing intervention. In the relative saturation design used in this study, each cluster is randomly allocated to one of the five bins (0%, 25%, 50%, 75% and 100%) of saturation, that means in a cluster allocated to 25% bin, only 25% randomly selected households are solicited for charitable donation via direct-marketing.
Within a cluster, households are randomly assigned to treatment groups. The content of the letter is determined using a cross-randomized design where specific messages are provided individually or jointly. On the top of the “basic appeal” content, we add four type of messages- Social distance, Information on the monetary value of subsidy, Signaling, Moral suasion. We further create two variations each under “Information on the monetary value of subsidy” and “Signaling”. This provides us total 36 groups, where a treated household is randomly assigned to. Finally, within the “Social distance” message, we randomly vary the examples on lines of caste-religion similarity.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.