Mismatch in beliefs between job seekers and employers in Iraq
How to cite
Martin, Diego. 2022. "Mismatch in beliefs between job seekers and employers in Iraq." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010446. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10446-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
I evaluate the preference of job seekers and employers using an incentivized resume rating (IRR), where subjects evaluate hypothetical vacancies and resumes. Employers will assess hypothetical CVs and choose the profile they would hire. Based on their elections, employers will receive three real candidates to fill vacancies. I will randomly assign an information treatment to half job seekers, showing the hiring rate of women, migration status, and living distance to the location. Job seekers will evaluate hypothetical vacancies, knowing they will receive three actual vacancies based on their assessment.
Intervention
Information treatment.
Employers will reveal their preference for employers after evaluating hypothetical candidates. From employers' choices, I will calculate the likelihood of a woman being hired using the number of business owners who would hire a woman divided by the total number of employers. I will calculate the same rate for men, migrants, non-migrants, and applicants living close or far away from the physical location of businesses.
For job seekers, I will ask them to estimate the likelihood of a woman finding a job in Iraq and the probability of migrants and candidates living close to a vacancy. Then, I will use an information treatment, where half of the sample will randomly receive a message saying: "The hiring rate of men is X1%, and the hiring rate of women is X2%." After receiving (or not receiving) the information treatment, job seekers will evaluate hypothetical vacancies, knowing they will receive three actual vacancies based on their assessment.
Experimental design
The research design consists of three parts: (i) elicit employers' preferences about hiring candidates. (ii) elicit preferences of job seekers about applying to vacancies. (iii) The treatment will randomly reveal employers' hiring rate to half of the job seekers in the data.
This study will use the incentivized resume rating (IRR) method to elicit the preference of employers and job seekers without deception. The IRR works in two steps. First, we build hypothetical resumes from real profiles and construct hypothetical vacancies from real job posts. Second, employers evaluate hypothetical resumes, and job seekers assess hypothetical vacancies.
To avoid deception, employers and job seekers know that they will evaluate hypothetical resumes and vacancies from the experiment's beginning. The IRR is an incentivized method to elicit preferences since employers will receive the three most suitable candidates depending on employers' evaluation. Similarly, we will send job seekers' profiles to the three most suitable vacancies based on the preferences of job seekers.
From eliciting employers' preferences, we will know the general trend in hiring rate by gender, migration status, and physical proximity to the vacancy. We will provide the following messages to the treated group and won't reveal any information for the control group. For example:
1. From our sample of employers, the hiring rate for women is 10%, and for men is 60%.
2. From our sample of employers, the hiring rate for workers from the host communities is 40%, and for candidates returning to the community is 80%.
3. From our sample of employers, the hiring rate for workers close to the vacancy is 80%, and for candidates residing far away is 20%.
First, we will show the first message about the hiring rate by gender. Second, we will deliver the second message about the hiring rate by migration status to candidates living in host communities and job seekers returning to the district. Finally, we will present the hiring rate by distance to the vacancy to candidates living close and far away.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.