Gender Identity and College Admissions
How to cite
McCannon, Bryan; Maupin, Ian. 2022. "Gender Identity and College Admissions." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010414. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10414-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
While race-based identify has become a salient issue in higher education admissions, we ask whether gender identity matters as well. Specifically, we ask whether non-binary/trans individuals experience discrimination in access to higher education. To address this question, we conduct an audit study. Email inquiries will be sent to admissions counselors at institutions of higher education in the United States. Emails will differ in their use of gender pronouns in the signature line. Our outcome variable of interest is whether we receive a reply to the email. The control will be emails without any use of pronouns. Emails with either he/him or she/her signatures identify the effect of using a pronoun, while a treatment with the use of xe/xem in the signature line will separately identify the effect of neo-pronouns from "traditional" pronouns. We hypothesize that the use of neo-pronouns will be associated with fewer responses to our email inquiries.
Intervention
We will select a random sample of higher education institutions in the U.S. We limit the study to 4-year institutions offering undergraduate degrees. From each institution, we will collect contact information for four admission counselors. Each counselor will receive one email from us. Each email will have the subject line "question" and the content of the email will be a question about which address to include (as our applicant will be moving soon). Treatments will differ in the signature line. The control will have no pronoun used. The male treatment will have "(he/him)" in the signature. The female treatment will have "(she/her)" in the signature line. The neo treatment will have "(xe/xem)" in the signature. The four counselors from each institution will receive a different treatment.
Experimental design
We will select a random sample of higher education institutions in the U.S. We limit the study to 4-year institutions offering undergraduate degrees. From each institution, we will collect contact information for four admission counselors. Each counselor will receive one email from us. Each email will have the subject line "question" and the content of the email will be a question about which address to include (as our applicant will be moving soon). Treatments will differ in the signature line. The control will have no pronoun used. The male treatment will have "(he/him)" in the signature. The female treatment will have "(she/her)" in the signature line. The neo treatment will have "(xe/xem)" in the signature. The four counselors from each institution will receive a different treatment.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.