The impact of role models on gender stereotypical beliefs about educational choices.

How to cite

astebro, thomas; Funck, Andrew; Altmejd, Adam; Mensmann, Mona; Wennberg, Karl; Mohammadi, Ali. 2022. "The impact of role models on gender stereotypical beliefs about educational choices.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010411. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10411-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

thomas astebro* , Andrew Funck , Adam Altmejd , Mona Mensmann , Karl Wennberg , Ali Mohammadi

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010411
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10411-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-11-16 – 2025-09-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10411

Abstract

We will investigate the effect of role gender stereotypes about STEM on the gender gap in STEM education. In an RCT, we will study how role models addressing gender occupational stereotypes can affect the beliefs and actual education choices of teenage students. We plan to study 15-18 year-old Swedish students (about 12,000 students) in 300 schools. Classes from participating schools will be randomly assigned to either one of 9 treatments or to control. Treated classes will receive one hour presentations from professionals working in STEM acting as role models or from a study counselor. The study follows a 3 x 3 design, where we randomly vary (a) the type of presenter (female role model, male role model, or study counselor/teacher), and (b) the category of stereotypical beliefs about STEM tackled in the presentation. We will then record educational choices of all students participating in the experiment and survey them on their perceptions about different occupations as well as their educational and occupational preferences. A random subset of students expressing interest in receiving personal advice about their educational choices will have the opportunity to talk individually with a role model.

Experimental design

The experiment will start in the autumn of 2022 in Malmö, Sweden. It is planned to continue for 3 years and to be scaled up to the national level. We will recruit subjects from the final grades of elementary school (9th grade) and STEM track high schools (3rd grade). Elementary school students apply to high school tracks in February, and high school students apply to university in April. The intervention will take place in the months preceding these periods.

Participating classes will be randomly assigned to either one of nine treatments, or to control. Six out of nine treated classes will receive one hour visits from professionals working in STEM and acting as role models. They will hold a presentation about the returns to career choices and job satisfaction in both STEM and non-STEM occupations, and will share their personal experience on job tasks, work environment and math skills that they needed to use in their careers. Role models will address one (randomly chosen) category of gender stereotypical occupational beliefs about working in STEM. Classes assigned to the remaining treatment condition will receive the same presentation, not from a role model but from a study counselor, while classes who will be assigned to the control condition will not receive any presentation.

The 3 × 3 treatment conditions will vary based on the type of presenter (female role model, male role model, school teacher) and the category of gender stereotypical beliefs about STEM that is discussed. To accurately measure individual change in beliefs and preferences, students will fill in the same questionnaire before and after role models’ visit. The questionnaire will contain questions about attitudes linked to occupational tasks, gender stereotypical perceptions of STEM occupations, self assessment of mathematical ability, study motivation, salary expectations, and perceptions of the work environment in STEM occupations. A random subset of students expressing interest in receiving personal advice about their educational choices will have the opportunity to talk individually with a role model after their visit.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization We plan to employ a stratified randomization procedure, stratifying elementary schools by socio-economic status. To do so we will use the Swedish SALSA scoring system. These scores predict student grades based on observables. We will use two stratas and randomize elementary schools separately by whether or not their SALSA score is above or below the mean of 232. Because we do not know which classes will end up participating each year, each class is randomized independently. Randomization Method Randomization is done using the attached R code.
Randomization unit
Randomization Unit Class level
Clusters
We plan to work with at least 600 classes, grouped in 300 schools. The actual number of participating classes will depend on the actual participation decision of eligible schools.
Observations
We aim to work with at least 600 classes. Assuming an average of 20 students per class, we expect to have at least 12,000 observations.
Arms
600 classes by 9 treatment arms = 66.6 classes per treatment * 20 students per class = 1300 students
Primary outcomes
1. Primary: Enrollment in STEM education (high school for elementary school subjects, university for high school subjects) 2. Survey measures of preference for STEM a) Stated intention to study and work in STEM b) Ranking of STEM fields and occupations 3. Beliefs about STEM a) career goals affordance b) career skills requirement c) workers characteristics
Sponsors
Name: HEC Foundation Location: Paris Url: https://www.hec.edu/en/overview/hec-foundation Name: Stockholm School of Economics Location: Stockholm Url: https://www.hhs.se/en/education/phd/

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords