(Not) Thinking About the Future: Maternal Labor Force Participation

How to cite

Costa-Ramon, Ana; Brenøe, Anne; Schaede, Ursina; Slotwinski, Michaela. 2022. "(Not) Thinking About the Future: Maternal Labor Force Participation." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010399. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10399-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ana Costa-Ramon* , Anne Brenøe , Ursina Schaede , Michaela Slotwinski

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010399
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10399-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-11-16 – 2024-11-16
Countries
Switzerland ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10399

Abstract

Despite considerable improvements in female labor market participation in the last decades, having children still has sizeable negative effects on mothers' labor supply and earnings. The gender gap in earnings due to parenthood is particularly striking in Switzerland: six years after having their first child, women's earnings are 75% lower compared to those of men. This means that upon entrance into parenthood, women, on average, forego a large proportion of their potential lifetime income. Among other things, this results in women systematically saving less for retirement than men.

This study aims to better understand why women decide to reduce their workload upon becoming mothers. We hypothesize that they do not fully factor in the longer-term financial costs of low or no labor force participation. To test this, we will conduct a field experiment among female teachers with children in Switzerland where we randomly inform women about the future long-term financial consequences of having a reduced workload. The treatment consists of an informational video discussing the long-term financial consequences for an example case and a tool that allows users to visualize the long-term financial implications of different workload scenarios for their individual case. We compare this treatment to a control group that receives videos with unrelated information.

We will analyze the impact of this intervention on women's financial awareness and behaviors, desired labor supply, and actual labor supply.

Intervention

To test whether learning about the long-term financial consequences of having a reduced workload impacts mothers’ behaviors, we designed the following intervention material:
1) Informational video containing three main dimensions of objective information about the long-term financial consequences of having a reduced workload that are relevant for teachers.
a. Information on the total earnings lost in the long-term
b. Information on the financial consequences for pensions
c. Information on the financial risk in case of adverse events (such as divorce)
The video also puts the lifetime financial losses in perspective to the short-term childcare costs.
2) Online tool: together with a Swiss bank, we designed an online calculator that allows users to simulate the long-term financial consequences of workload reductions for their individual case. We again provide information about the total earnings loss, the pensions loss, and the comparison with the short-term childcare costs. The tool automatically gathers the individual calculations' data, so we can link them to the individual.

The control group receives a video of similar duration but on an unrelated topic. We use videos created by the national public television as part of their regular programming (https://www.srf.ch/). We randomize the control group into three videos:
- a video containing information about the gender pay gap in Switzerland
- a video with information on proposed tax breaks for families in Switzerland
- a video discussing the current structure of costs of renting or buying housing in Switzerland

In the online baseline survey, participants watch their assigned video. The treatment group receives the online calculator by email directly after completing the baseline. For outcomes in the baseline survey, participants will have received the information in the treatment video only.

Experimental design

We are collaborating with cantonal Departments of Education in Switzerland. In three cantons, we have access to the contact information of female staff aged between 25 and 50 in cantonal employment contracts, including kindergarten, primary, and secondary school teachers, for the school year 2022/23. We invite teachers to our study by email (if available) and by letter (all).

We conduct an individual-level randomization of teachers into the treatment and control groups. Due to the potential presence of spillovers between teachers working in the same school, we add a hold-out control group to this design. For the largest canton (in the following: Canton 1), we thus implement a two-stage randomization in the following way:

1. In the first stage, we randomize 2/3 of the schools into treatment schools and 1/3 into control schools (from now on referred to as the “pure control group”). We stratify the sample by terciles of school size (proxied by the number of female teachers aged 25-50 years working in each school based on the Department of Education contact list), school type (primary or secondary), and type of municipality (rural, semi-urban, city).

2. In the second stage, we randomize teachers in treatment schools at the individual level to treatment or control when participating in the survey. The individual-level randomization occurs during the survey, just before the intervention video starts playing. We assign ½ of the teachers to treatment and the rest to control.

For the rest of the cantons, we only randomize at the individual level (i.e., only the second step) and stratify by canton. Within the control group (both for the pure control and for the control), we randomize three control videos with equal probability. Our main focus for the analysis is the individual-level randomization of teachers into the treatment and control groups.

Design details

Randomization method
Individual-level randomization is performed with Qualtrics. The school-level randomization by computer.
Randomization unit
Our main randomization is at the individual level. For Canton 1, we implement a two-stage randomization in the following way: we first randomize schools into treatment and control ("pure control group"), and in a second stage, we randomize at the individual level teachers in treated schools into treatment or control during the survey.
Clusters
Canton 1: we invite 9281 teachers to our study. We randomized 330 schools to the treatment group and 165 schools to the pure control group. Our sample's final number of schools will depend on the response rate. The same applies to the final number of teachers who will be randomized to treatment and control within treatment schools. Canton 2: we invite around 1900 teachers from 86 schools. Again, the final number of teachers randomized to treatment and control will depend on the response rate. Canton 3: we invite around 548 teachers from 93 schools.
Observations
2000 teachers
Arms
Individual level treatment assignment in all 3 cantons: In total, we expect around 1000 teachers per treatment arm for the individual level. (For the school-level randomization in canton 1 to analyze potential spillovers: 330 schools are in the treatment group and 165 schools are in the pure control group.)
Primary outcomes
We have three primary outcomes dimensions: a) Financial empowerment: women’s financial awareness and the likelihood of considering long-term financial factors. b) Workload aspirations: teachers’ desired future workload c) Workload: teachers’ actual workload in the next school year (administrative data)
Secondary outcomes
We are also interested in the heterogeneity of the background characteristics of respondents and will thus look at outcomes by sub-groups. In particular, for the financial dimension, we will consider heterogeneity by financial awareness at baseline, the workload at baseline, and marital status. For the labor force participation dimensions (both desired and actual LFP), we will analyze heterogeneous effects by financial awareness at baseline, gender norms, the workload at baseline, the self-reported difficulty of organizing family life, self-reported flexibility in adjusting their workload, beliefs about the quality of external care, and by mother’s age and age of the youngest child.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords