The Effectiveness of Digital Reminders to Improve Small Businesses’ Tax Compliance in Indonesia: A Randomised Controlled Trial
How to cite
Yogama, Eko Arief; Rablen, Matthew D.; Gray, Daniel J.. 2022. "The Effectiveness of Digital Reminders to Improve Small Businesses’ Tax Compliance in Indonesia: A Randomised Controlled Trial." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010387. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10387-1.3
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Boosting small-medium enterprises (SMEs) tax compliance is essential as SMEs contribute to a significant portion of GDP. SMEs are often characterised by low tax compliance due to low tax literacy. Reminders combined with deterrence messages will be used to induce timeliness in SMEs' monthly income tax payments. This study seeks to answer how the variations of timing and frequency affect a taxpayer's decision to pay or not their monthly income tax. Four message timing and frequency delivery variations will be tested, namely Early, Close, Combined, and Post. The message will be sent through a digital channel, WhatsApp, Indonesia's most popular messaging application. The design of the
message consists of a picture reflecting the monthly income taxes payment and filing deadlines and some text stating the financial and legal consequences of no or late payment and filing. A particular interest of our study is how long taxpayers continue to pay the tax after receiving the message. To analyse this, we employ an inverse survival approach. A survival function, in our context, represents tax non-compliance. The treatment effect, which indicates the differences between treatment groups, will be estimated using a Logit model. It is expected that the results of this study will serve as resourceful guidance for policymakers, primarily the tax authority, to increase tax compliance among SMEs in a
cost-efficient channel. In addition, it also provides a reference regarding the most effective timing of sending a message to taxpayers and how often the message should be delivered.
Intervention
We designed a message containing graphic information on SME monthly tax payment deadline and a text expressing penalties for not paying and reporting taxes on time. The message will be delivered to individual and small firm taxpayers who satisfy the sampling criteria through a WhatsApp digital channel. Indonesia is one of the fifth largest users of WhatsApp. Therefore, the usage of WhatsApp as a delivery channel is considered more preferred and justifiable compared to other digital channels such as email and short message services (SMS).
The sample will be divided into five groups: Control (no message), Early (13 days before payment deadline), Close (2 days before payment deadline), Combined (13 days and 2 days before payment deadline), and Post (3 days after payment deadline). The messages will be dispatched following the period below:
The monthly income tax payment deadline for SMEs is day 15th of the following month
The monthly income tax payment reporting deadline for SMEs is day 20th of the following month
Control: No message will be sent
Early: The message will be sent 13 days before the payment deadline
Close: The message will be sent 2 days before the payment deadline
Combined: The message will be sent twice, within 13 days and 2 days before the payment deadline
Post: The message will be sent 3 days before the reporting deadline
Experimental design
Message design:
============================================================================================================
--- picture ---
"Please pay your monthly income taxes as early as possible. A late filing penalty of Rp 100,000 will be imposed for late tax return filing, and an additional late payment penalty will also be imposed if you have late payments."
"According to Law No. 9/2017, Banks and Other Financial Institutions are required to provide their customers' account information periodically. Therefore, all recorded financial transactions could be detected by the DGT."
"For further information, you may access our website at https://pajak.go.id or call us through the national call centre 1500200."
"Your registered tax office: <Tax Office> can be reached directly by WhatsApp number listed in https://pajak.go.id/id/unit-kerja."
============================================================================================================
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.