It takes a village: A Pilot Study Encouraging Women to Use Maternal Care through Community Involvement
How to cite
Jakubowski, Aleksandra; Abuosi, Aaron. 2022. "It takes a village: A Pilot Study Encouraging Women to Use Maternal Care through Community Involvement." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010360. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10360-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
The World Health Organization (WHO) recommends a minimum of eight antenatal care (ANC) contacts, initiating ANC during first trimester, giving birth in facilities, and postnatal care (PNC) within 24 hours of birth to reduce maternal and perinatal mortality. These recommendations specifically refer to ANC “contacts” instead of “visits” to place the emphasis on continuous interactions between providers and pregnant women that does not necessarily imply a physical visit to health facility. In Ghana, although attendance of at least one ANC visit is nearly universal, attendance of the recommended number of visits remains below target, women typically start ANC late in pregnancy, and many still do not deliver in a health facility. Though it is the woman who bears the pregnancy, in Ghana and many other patriarchal societies, decisions to seek health services are often made by other stakeholders. For instance, it is often the mother-in-law who makes decisions about the merits of ANC and the husband who makes the financial decision. Many programs ignore this reality. We propose to test an intervention that focuses not only on encouraging pregnant women but also their support networks about the importance of seeking modern maternal care, taking into account deeply entrenched cultural beliefs.
Intervention
The study involved two cross-randomized interventions: 1) community education at durbars, 2) enhanced ANC model during which monthly phone calls and one home visit were made to reinforce key messages, monitor pregnancy, and prepare birth plans together with husbands and mothers-in-law.
Durbars are village meetings where communities discuss important village matters. Since durbars take place on a usual basis, nurses coordinated with the local chiefs and elders to pre-arrange durbars to deliver the interventions. The chiefs and elders in turn employed their mechanisms of organizing durbars to invite the community members to participate. The key quality of durbars that we leveraged in our intervention is that these are ongoing meetings that happen on a regular basis and that involve village chiefs and other local authority figures who wield significant influence in the communities, and whose endorsement of the messages about the traditional beliefs about seeking ANC early and male involvement might be taken seriously. We sought the endorsement of our messages from the chiefs and elders prior to the durbars. Participation in the durbars was completely voluntary and was not monitored by research staff - community members came to these meetings when they wished, and they were free to leave whenever they deemed appropriate. We tested the impact of providing education about the importance of starting ANC in the first trimester by comparing whether the month of pregnancy when women first presented for ANC changed in the villages that held durbars vs. those that did not.
The durbars were held prior to any subject recruitment - we collected no identifiable or individual-level information about who attends the durbars. We obtained very general information about durbar attendance, but this information was tracked at the aggregate level using publicly observable information about the meetings (e.g. number of people, gender breakdown). This general attendance information helped us address the question of whether well attended & gender balanced durbars had larger impact.
After durbars were held, the study staff began enrolling women in the five study facilities. Women who agreed to participate were provided informed consent, were randomized to routine care or Enhanced ANC intervention which consisted of monthly phone calls and one home visit
Monthly calls: it was a follow-up on the progress of the pregnancy, encouraged women to come to the facility for in-person ANC check, and developed a birth preparedness plan. The innovation of this treatment is that instead of receiving pre-recorded messages (i.e. the CHPS program) women were connected with a midwife who can go over any possible complications and encouraged them to go in for a check-up. This activity was conducted by the nurses/midwives. Research staff were not involved in this activity.
Home visit: women randomized to this arm received one household visit from a community health officer (CHO) to develop a concrete birth preparedness plan with the pregnant woman and her household members. The health provider arranged a time to visit the household when either the woman’s husband or mother-in-law (ideally both) were at home, ensuring that the families developed a plan together. The health provider prompted the households to make specific choices for the plan, such as: identifying danger signs during pregnancy and labor, choosing the health facility where the woman can deliver, determining how long it takes to travel there, making specific plan on how they will travel there, establishing how much money was required for the birthing process, and planning how to set aside money for this expense. This activity was conducted by the nurses/midwives. Research staff were not involved in this activity.
Randomization to the durbar treatment was at the village-level; randomization to the phone call and home visit treatments was at the woman-level. The cross-randomization was to enable us to tease out the specific aspects of these intervention on outcomes of interest. Women who were randomized to the pure control arm received standard of care: encouraged to return for at least eight ANC contacts, to deliver in a health facility, and have a postnatal check each time she has contact with health providers.
Experimental design
Our study is designed to test whether education at durbars (or community meetings) to communicate the importance of timely and frequent prenatal care, combined with phone messages to reinforce the education, and household visits to develop birth preparedness plans with pregnant women, their partners, and mothers-in-law increases the use of maternal health services and improves health outcomes in northern Ghana. The general outline of our interventions and data collection procedures is as follows:
1. Random assignment of which communities receive ANC messages at durbars
2. Intervention 1: Education at durbars
3. Recruit and enroll pregnant women in study at 1st antenatal visit
4. Randomize individuals to receive phone calls and home visits
5. Conduct baseline survey (in person)
6. Intervention 2: Phone calls (monthly) and home visit (one time)
7. Conduct endline survey (in person unless women express preference for phone interview)
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.