Matching Children with Level-Appropriate Books and Engaging Families
How to cite
Aguilar, Arturo; Ortega, Maria Elena. 2017. "Matching Children with Level-Appropriate Books and Engaging Families." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001034. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1034-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Reading skills are an important predictor of educational attainment and, consequently, of other long-term outcomes. School curriculum often follows the “one size fits all” rule, which means that every student within a classroom is assigned the same reading materials, regardless of their reading skills. This practice potentially leads to adverse effects for students in the extremes of the reading abilities’ distribution, which is particularly negative for those falling behind. In this project, we test an alternative system to select reading material for early grade readers: we build a web-based platform that gives book recommendations tailored to readers’ abilities and interests; participants can borrow books for free at the community library. We also test whether parental involvement could complement this strategy. We implement a randomized control trial to assess the potential benefits of this intervention on students’ reading proficiency and habits.
Intervention
The presented intervention, hereon "Mundo de Libros" (MdL), program aims to improve reading skills and habits of primary students enrolled in Grades 1 to 3 in Spanish-speaking countries. This free program is independent of their school curriculum and runs in community libraries. The intervention has three core components:
1. Access to children’s books at the library and that can be taken home. Children have a program passport – similar to a library card – that allows them to borrow books and keep track of due-dates. Each library is equipped with a stock of 720 children’s books. The book collection is diverse in terms of difficulty and topics, thus ensuring that every child will have a wide spectrum of choices. All books in the project are new at the time of the start of the intervention.
2. Access to an individual profile (with login and password) through the web-based platform (www.mundodelibros.mx). Each child’s profile on the platform gives them personalized book recommendations according to their assessed level of vocabulary and reading skills. These recommendations are determined by QfD’s MATCH algorithm that takes into account the reading level of each child and the characteristics of each book. The reading level of the child is determined with an initial test that includes the EGRA and Peabody Picture Vocabulary standardized tests. After logging into the site, participants see recommendations, are able to filter titles according to interests, and search for specific titles, authors or words. The website also allows users to rate the books (on a scale of one to five) after returning them, which is later used to give recommendations based on their interest.
3. Workshops and materials for parents or caregivers. The main objectives of these workshops and materials is to: (i) promote parental engagement, (ii) provide information and strategies to scaffold their children’s reading practices, and (iii) advise how to create a rich literacy environment at home. Workshops for parents or caregivers take place every two months.
Experimental design
To evaluate the effect of the components of the “Mundo de Libros” program, the implementation sites (libraries) were divided in two groups based on parental workshops. Five libraries were selected to receive bi-monthly workshops for parents/guardians and five were selected to act as control libraries regarding the parental workshop component. Then, within each library, half of the participating children were randomly assigned to have access to the adequate-level book recommendations (using the matching algorithm) through the Internet-based platform. The other also had access to the platform but were selected to receive random recommendations (i.e. not matched to their abilities and interests). All the libraries and students have access to the same stock of 721 books and to the same web-based platform, including the loan history and book search tools. To summarize, 4 experimental groups are:
[A] Parent workshop & adequate-level book recommendations
[B] Parent workshop & random book recommendations
[C] No parent workshop & adequate-level book recommendations
[D] No Parent workshop & random book recommendations
Using this design, the effect of receiving adequate-level book recommendations will be assessed through a weighted average of the comparisons [A] to [B] and [C] to [D] groups. Similarly, the workshop component (research question 2) could be evaluated through a weighted average of the comparisons between [A] - [C] and [B] - [D]. Assignment in this case is not individual since the likelihood of contamination is higher. If complementarities between the parent workshop and the MATCH algorithm exist, it is likely that the effect of comparing [A] to [B] will be higher than that comparing [C] to [D].
Qualitative analysis and fidelity of implementation (FOI) will complement the quantitative assessment and will be used as the main strategy to evaluate potential benefits of the different components of the program.
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.