The Last Meter: Incentivizing Lead Water Service Line Inspections among Hard-to-Reach Populations in Trenton, NJ.

How to cite

Gazze, Ludovica; Greenstone, Michael; Hodel, Leslie; Klemick, Heather; Wolverton, Ann; Parthum, Bryan. 2022. "The Last Meter: Incentivizing Lead Water Service Line Inspections among Hard-to-Reach Populations in Trenton, NJ.." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010330. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10330-2.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ludovica Gazze* , Michael Greenstone , Leslie Hodel , Heather Klemick , Ann Wolverton , Bryan Parthum

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010330
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10330-2.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-07-26 – 2024-01-08
Countries
United States of America (New Jersey)
JEL codes
Q53, O18
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10330

Abstract

Despite federal law banning the use of new lead service lines in drinking water systems for decades due to their detrimental health effects, an estimated 9.7 to 12.8 million legacy lead service lines (LSLs) connect water mains to homes in the United States (NRDC 2021). Many public water systems are struggling to locate and replace lead pipes with safe alternatives, particularly due to the scale of the problem and persistent challenges of gaining cooperation from some segments of the population.

The purpose of this study is to investigate the efficacy of interventions designed to overcome the barriers public water systems face when trying to locate lead service lines in these “hard-to-reach” populations. In partnership with Trenton Water Works, a major public utility in Trenton, New Jersey, we will test several different interventions encouraging members of these “hard-to-reach” populations to submit a simple “self-inspection” of their pipes (consisting primarily of photos of the pipes) to the utility to help them locate lead on the private, homeowner side of the service line.

Intervention

This project studied several interventions designed to encourage addresses to make use of the local lead service line self-inspection program, which allows residents to submit photos of their service lines to have their material identified. Addresses will be assigned to one of the following treatments: an informational treatment consisting of distributed materials explaining the program, or a financial incentive treatment consisting of the same materials, but with the offer of a gift card reward for participating in the program.

Addresses that do not respond to treatment after one month will receive one of the following cross-randomized treatment enhancements to allow us to estimate the costs and impacts of varied treatment intensities to inform policy feasibility at scale in Phase 2: remote outreach via email, SMS, or both requesting them to complete the self-inspection.

Experimental design

This study focuses on the impact of different outreach and engagement methods designed to encourage households to submit a self-inspection of their service lines to help the local utility identify which addresses have lead service lines connecting them to the water system.

Each address in our sample of 9,000 is assigned to one of three roughly equal-sized experimental groups of 3,000 addresses – Treatment 1 (information only), Treatment 2 (information and financial incentive), or Control (no further outreach or incentive). Participating households will submit photos of their service line online, following instructions to ensure they are of sufficient quality for trained staff to identify the service line material.

For Phase 2, after one month, we will randomize all addresses that were assigned to Treatment 1 or 2 but did not respond to the intervention into one of three, equal-sized, cross-randomized, secondary treatments – Secondary Treatment 1 (remote outreach), Secondary Treatment 2 (remote outreach and financial incentive), or Control (no additional treatment).

We will principally examine the difference in uptake between each of these interventions and the control. We will also compare the difference in uptake between different levels of financial incentive to trace demand curves for the program, and will examine the prevalence of lead among respondents at different levels of incentive to assess if households that already know they do not have lead are less likely to participate in the absence of a high incentive.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomized assignment before treatment done in office by a computer
Randomization unit
Residential address
Clusters
9,000 residential addresses
Observations
9,000 residential addresses
Arms
Control: 3,000 residential addresses Treatment 1 (information only): 3,000 residential addresses Treatment 2a ($10 incentive): 875 residential addresses Treatment 2b ($25 incentive): 875 residential addresses Treatment 2c ($50 incentive): 750 residential addresses Treatment 2d ($100 incentive): 500 addresses
Primary outcomes
Participation in lead service line self-inspection program
Secondary outcomes
Water service line material

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords