Learning in the Limit: Income Inference from Credit Extension
How to cite
Yin, Xiao. 2022. "Learning in the Limit: Income Inference from Credit Extension." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010315. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10315-1.0
Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.
* Primary investigator
Abstract
Combining a randomized controlled trial with bank account and survey data, I show that credit-limit extensions significantly increase consumer expectations about their future income. A one-dollar increase in credit limits raises consumer income expectations over the next six months by 40 cents and total consumption by 34 cents. The expectation changes explain around 35% of the total spending responses to credit limit extensions. The results show that consumers infer information from lenders' credit-supply decisions, and this learning behavior impacts consumers' economic decision-making greatly.
Experimental design
I work with a commercial bank in China to perform the RCT. At the end of March 2020, the bank selected a group of consumers and decided on a new credit limit that was higher than this group of customers’ current credit card limit, based on the bank’s own proprietary rules. A random sample of approximately 16,000 consumers was selected from the group of consumers as the potential subjects in this study. Of the selected subjects, 7,000 consumers were randomly selected to form the control group, and the rest formed the treatment group. Between April 5 and April 12, the participants in the treatment group were informed about the opportunity to increase their credit card limits to the
amount offered by the bank. They could decide to either accept or ignore the offer within one week of the extension. The control-group offers were postponed to the beginning of October 2020.
Within one week before and after the experiment, we sent out a survey to the participants to ask for their beliefs about their future income, spending, saving, etc. The participants were informed that the survey would be used to study the expectations and preferences of representative credit card holders in China and that the information would be used for only scientific research purposes.
A random 15% of the participants were shown the following information on top of the post-experiment survey:
"To test their business strategies, banks often randomly select some people to have a change in their credit card limits and see how they change their spending."
Design details
Cited by
No citation data available for this registration yet.