An Experiment on the Cultural Interpretation of Meritocracy

How to cite

Huang, Yuchen; Mo, Zhexun; Belguise, Margot. 2022. "An Experiment on the Cultural Interpretation of Meritocracy." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010274. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10274-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Yuchen Huang* , Zhexun Mo , Margot Belguise

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010274
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10274-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
In development
Trial dates
2022-11-22 – 2023-04-30
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10274

Abstract

While in Western developed countries people establish a firm link between their beliefs in the importance of merit (as opposed to luck and privilege) in the income generating process and the desired level of redistribution, this significant correlation is not observed in East Asian countries despite a tradition of meritocratic civil service exams with competitive selection and a heavy focus on education. We argue that the concept of meritocracy takes different forms in Asia versus in Europe. We make a distinction between "consequentialist" meritocracy and "deontological" meritocracy, with the former adopting meritocracy as a means of maximising total surplus and the latter aiming at distributing resources proportional to intrinsic merits. We predict that these two types of meritocracy interpretations would generate different distributional preferences, and empirically test it with incentivised spectator games with students from highly selective colleges of different cultures. Spectators are asked to make redistribution choices in a series of scenarios provided to them. We randomize the status-quo income distribution described in the scenarios, by assigning half of the spectators to a highly unequal status-quo distribution (winner takes all) and the other half to an almost equal status-quo distribution. We compare both the sums redistributed and the Gini coefficients implemented by spectators of different cultures, in order to disentangle preference for inequality from status-quo bias. In order to test our predictions of which meritocracy considerations Western (deontological meritocrats) and East Asian (consequentialist meritocrats) respondents would privilege when faced with ethical trade-offs, we compare the redistribution choices made by spectators in a baseline scenario where the initial income distribution is determined by performance on a task, with their redistribution choices in scenarios where ethical trade-offs arise.

Experimental design

In this project, we plan to experimentally test a series of predictions on the differences in the distributional choices which deontological and consequentialist meritocrats would make. Specifically, we will ask our respondents to indicate how they want us to distribute bonus payments between two workers. We will randomise the content, framing and order of the scenarios that they will choose to elicit their true distributional preferences. Respondents’ choices will be actually implemented with given probabilities, as we will hire Amazon MTurk workers to solve effort-paying tasks and re-enact the scenarios described in the survey and will randomly draw the bonus schedule to be paid to the workers from the respondents’ answers.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomisation is done by the inbuilt function of QUALTRICS system for the French sample and by a Chinese survey company for the Chinese sample.
Randomization unit
Treatments (status-quo income distribution, framing of the wrong winner / wrong loser scenario, as well as the order of scenarios) will be randomised at the individual level.
Clusters
There are three sample groups: undergraduate students in France who specialised in Europeans studies in a given university campus, undergraduate students in France who specialised in Euro-Asian studies in another separate university campus, and undergraduate students in China from a randomly drawn online sample.
Observations
The French sample is expected to be around 300 to 500 students (depending on the take-up rate of the survey as we will be distributing our surveys among undergraduate college students across two campuses of the same university). The Chinese college student sample is fixed to be 400.
Arms
Our main randomization strategies, such as the randomization into different status-quo income distributions and the randomization into different framings of the scenarios on winning/losing, are at the same level (not a two-stage randomization), as such essentially we will be splitting our sample into two halves, with 200 individuals per treatment arm for the Chinese sample. Treatment arm sizes for the French sample will depend on the take-up rate of our survey, but we expect to arrive at similar treatment group sizes there as the Chinese sample.
Primary outcomes
Our dependent variables are the sums redistributed by the spectators and the Gini coefficients the spectators implement.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords