Using a Mobile Application to Connect Schools and Farmers for Improved Meal Provisions: Experimental Evidence from a Pilot Study through Guatemala's School Feeding Program

How to cite

Scot, Thiago; Jeong, Dahyeon; Kondylis, Florence; Heirman, Jonas; Lombardini, Simone. 2023. "Using a Mobile Application to Connect Schools and Farmers for Improved Meal Provisions: Experimental Evidence from a Pilot Study through Guatemala's School Feeding Program." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010267. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10267-1.1

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Thiago Scot* , Dahyeon Jeong , Florence Kondylis , Jonas Heirman , Simone Lombardini

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010267
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10267-1.1
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-07-15 – 2023-07-15
Countries
Private
JEL codes
H57: Procurement; Q13: Agricultural Markets and Marketing; D83: Search
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10267

Abstract

This study evaluates the impact of a mobile app designed to reduce frictions in agricultural output markets in the context of a government-led home-grown school feeding program in Guatemala. To prepare school meals, schools make purchase orders of ingredients using the app which are then shared for local farmers to make competitive offers. In coordination with the government and World Food Programme, we conduct a municipality-level random assignment where 30 municipalities are introduced to the mobile app (‘’treatment group”) and 29 municipalities are not (“control group”). The study leverages administrative data, high frequency phone survey, and in-person endline surveys to measure the impacts of introducing the mobile app on take-up, readiness, and procurement behaviors (e.g. adherence to the government-proposed menus, procurement efficiency, quantity and prices of food by types of sellers).

Intervention

To encourage market participation from family farmers and to facilitate market transactions, the Guatemala WFP CO developed the School Feeding Management Application (SFMA or ’the app’), a smartphone application that connects schools and registered suppliers in the nearby area. Without the app, schools are often dependent on large-scale agricultural producers and/or intermediaries, who make it difficult for schools to procure directly from small-holder farmers. Introduced in 2017, the Guatemalan Ley de Alimentación Escolar (LAE) aims to both ensure that all Guatemalan primary-school children have access to nutritional school meals as well as increasing procurement from local small-holder farmers (suppliers) to 50% of purchases. The app thus assists in facilitating the connection between schools and local suppliers in support of the LAE, allowing schools and suppliers to easily submit orders and place bids, respectively, on this digital marketplace.

There are several goals this app aims to achieve. First, to strengthen the school procurement process by increasing the supply of locally produced nutritious food in thousands of schools in Guatemala where the app is implemented. Second, to increase its efficiency by reducing search and transaction costs. Finally, to improve the local economy by encouraging suppliers to sell food to schools.

The pilot will be implemented in six departments of Guatemala (Alta Verapaz, Chimaltenango, Chiquimula, El Progreso, Escuintla, and San Marcos). Training will be organized in schools with OPFs and suppliers to cover the importance of the LAE, Guatemala’s school feeding law, and compliance with the requirements of the law. MINEDUC and MAGA will also provide additional detailed training on the new procurement app to promote the use of the app among OPFs and suppliers.

This app can potentially support the LAE in developing agricultural markets in predominantly agricultural communities, which would positively impact local cooperatives and farmers. If the app improves the efficiency of market transactions, then it may also lead to increased quality and diversity of meals such that they adhere to the government-suggested menu.

While treatment and control status for schools and suppliers are decided by the treatment status of the municipality they belong to, both control and treatment schools and suppliers will receive training and be reminded on the importance of the LAE, compliance with the requirements of the law, and general procurement process. The only difference between the control and treatment groups is that treatment schools and suppliers will be trained on the use of the new SFMA app. Providing training to both control and treatment groups ensures that any changes in outcomes is attributable to the differences in the training content.

Experimental design

The design of the app roll-out is a randomization at the municipality level of the 59 municipalities in the study, including 210 sampled schools and up to 535 MAGA registered suppliers in six departments of Guatemala.

Of the 59 municipalities, 30 municipalities were then randomly assigned to the treatment group and 29 to control. This corresponds to 210 schools as part of the impact evaluation sample, divided as follows: 108 schools in the treatment group and 102 schools in the control group. All 535 MAGA registered suppliers in the 59 municipalities will be targeted; 271 registered suppliers in the treatment group and 264 registered suppliers in the control group.

Design details

Randomization method
The sampling and randomization were conducted using Stata software.
Randomization unit
Municipalities Treatment group: 30 municipalities. 108 schools and up to 271 registered suppliers. Control group: 29 municipalities. 102 schools and up to 264 registered suppliers
Clusters
59 municipalities in Guatemala (340 municipalities total in Guatemala).
Observations
210 schools are sampled from the 59 municipalities (326 total schools in the 59 municipalities). 535 registered suppliers are sampled from the 59 municipalities (535 total registered suppliers in the 59 municipalities).
Arms
Treatment: 108 schools and 271 suppliers in 30 municipalities Control: 102 schools and 264 suppliers in 29 municipalities
Primary outcomes
Service delivery; Food procurement; Supplier production and sales; App experience (treatment group only)

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords