Demand for Nontraditional Cookstoves in Bangladesh

How to cite

Miller, Grant; Hildemann, Lynn; Bailis, Robert; Diwedi, Puneet; Mobarak, Ahmed Mushfiq. 2016. "Demand for Nontraditional Cookstoves in Bangladesh." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0001024. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1024-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Grant Miller* , Lynn Hildemann , Robert Bailis , Puneet Diwedi , Ahmed Mushfiq Mobarak

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0001024
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.1024-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2006-07-06 – 2011-02-28
Countries
Bangladesh (South Asia)
JEL codes
Q52, O1, Q4
Secondary IDs
ISRCTN85847827
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/1024

Abstract

There are few marketing studies of social learning about new technologies in low income countries. This paper examines how learning through opinion leaders and social networks influences demand for non-traditional cookstoves – a technology with important health and environmental consequences for developing country populations. We conduct marketing interventions in rural Bangladesh to assess how
stove adoption decisions respond to (a) learning the adoption choices of locally identified ‘opinion leaders’ and (b) learning about stove attributes and performance through social networks. We find that households generally draw negative inferences about stoves through social learning, and that social learning is more important for stoves with less evident benefits. In an institutional environment in which consumers are distrustful of new products and brands, consumers appear to rely on their networks more to learn about negative product attributes. Overall, our findings imply that external information and marketing campaigns can induce initial adoption and experiential learning about unfamiliar technologies, but sustained use ultimately requires that new technologies match local preferences.

Intervention

Despite much concerted global effort, demand for improved cookstoves remains low. The trial seeks to understand this issue by testing (i) price sensitivity for improved cookstoves (ii) how preference for the stoves varies by gender and (iii) whether social networks influence uptake decision.

The trial was conducted in in two rural sub-districts of Bangladesh where sample households were offered two variants of improved cookstoves - a chimney stove and an efficiency stove - at a variety of price points: free, half-priced and full-priced. Husband and wife were provided marketing information separately and in half the households only the men were allowed to place an order while in the other half only the women could place the order. Opinion leaders in the village were also given the same offers and their choices were announced in the village to see whether their adoption decision affects the adoption decision of other households. Finally, households within the social network of those who decided to use the cookstoves were also sampled to see whether they were convinced to make a purchase with information from those who had actually used the product.

Experimental design

In the gender experiment, villages were randomized to receive either free or highly subsidized improved cooking stoves and households were randomized to decide whether the husband or the wife shall receive the offer to purchase the stove. A team of two enumerators visited sample households and provided marketing information about the benefits of two types of improved cooking stoves – the chimney stove and the efficiency stove. After the information session, depending on the treatment group, either the husband or wife was offered an opportunity to pre-order either type of stove, but was not allowed to consult with his/her spouse before making the decision. Households were not required to pay at the pre-order stage nor was the pre-order binding. They would pay the price of the stove once the stove was delivered and were free to change their mind upto the point of delivery. This setup allows the study of unconstrained gender differences in prioritization of budget-saving and health-improving technologies. Alternatively, gender differences when stoves are free vs. when small positive prices are charged uncovers the degree to which each gender is able to act on their underlying differences in preferences in the presence of positive prices.

In the social network experiment, a two-stage intervention was made. In the first-stage, three village opinion leaders were identified through focus group discussions. The villages were then randomized to receive either the chimney or efficiency stove at full or half price. In half the villages, the opinion leaders were first offered the cookstoves and their adoption decision was made known to subsequent households who receive the offer. In the other half of the villages, opinion leaders were not engaged. Like the first experiment, households did not have to pay when placing the order and were free to cancel the order upto the point of delivery. In the second-stage intervention, households with social links to first-stage households that purchased an improved stove were offered to buy stoves themselves. This allows the trial to observe whether purchase decisions are affected when participants know their leaders making decisions with the same amount of information as themselves vs. when their social network has more knowledge than they do by virtue of actually adopting and using the cookstoves.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by computer.
Randomization unit
Village, household, para (neighborhood: each village divided in into 3 paras) depending on experiment. 1. Price: randomized at the village level. 22 villages were chosen to receive stoves at full price, 20 remaining villages received stoves at half price. Total 42 villages 2. Gender: randomized at the household level for 800 households. 3. Opinion Leader: randomized at para level. Each village was divided into three 3 paras thus giving 66 full-priced paras and 60 half priced paras. In the full price paras, 30 were randomly assigned an opinion leader while the remaining 33 were not. Likewise in the 60 half- priced paras, half were randomly allocated opinion leaders while the other half were not. Total 126 paras.
Clusters
Gender clusters: Half-price stove: 8 villages Free stove: 8 villages Husband choice: 200 households Wife choice: 200 households Social Network clusters: Full price opinion-leader: 30 paras Half-price opinion-leader: 30 paras Full price no opinion leader: 36 paras Half-price opinion leader: 30 paras Cookstove cluster: Efficient cookstoves: 20 villages Chimney cookstoves: 22 villages
Observations
Gender experiment: 800 households (50 per village x 16 villages) Social network experiment: 2268 households ( 54 per village x 42 villages)
Arms
Gender study: Free stove: 8 villages x 50 households per village = 400 Half-price stove: 8 village x 50 households per village =400 Social network study: 1620 treatment, 648 control Full price opinion-leader: 10 villages x 54 per village = 540 households Half-price opinion-leader: 10 villages x 54 per village = 540 households Full price no opinion leader: 12 villages x 54 per village = 648 households (control) Half-price opinion leader: 10 village x 54 per village = 540 households
Primary outcomes
1. Price sensitivity of demand for two non-traditional cookstoves technologies 2. How gender affects choice to adopt improved cookstoves. 3. The degree to which each gender is able to act on their preferences when prices go up. 4. How inter-spouse consultation changes original decision of each spouse. 5. Impact of opinion leaders in increasing adoption. 6. Impact of social network in increasing adoption

Papers from this trial

  1. Arif, Tamid, Anik Ashraf, Grant Miller, Ahmed Mushfiqu Mobarak, Nasima Akter, ARM Mehrab Ali, MA Quaiyum Sarkar, Lynn Hildemann, Nepal C Dey, Mizanur Rahman, Puneet Dwivedi, and Paul Wise. "Promotion of Improved Cookstove in Rural Bangladesh." Working Paper No. 22, BRAC, May 2011. http://cleancookstoves.org/resources_files/promotion-of-improved.pdf
  2. Mobarak, Ahmed Mushfiz, Puneet Dwivedi, Robert Bailis, Lynn Hildemann, and Grant Miller. "Low Demand for Nontraditional Cookstove Technologies." Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS) 109(27): 10815-20. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/298%20June%202012.pdf
  3. Miller, Grant, and A. Mushfiq Mobarak. "Learning About New Technologies Through Social Networks: Experimental Evidence on Non-Traditional Stoves in Bangladesh." Working Paper, September 2013. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/298_398%20Learning%20new%20technologies%20Sept2013.pdf
  4. Miller, Grant, and A. Mushifq Mobarak. "Gender Differences in Preferences, Intra-Household Externalities, and the Low Demand for Improved Cookstoves." Working Paper, Stanford University, January 2013. https://www.povertyactionlab.org/sites/default/files/publications/stove_long.pdf

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords