Math skills, perceptions of fit, and occupational choice

How to cite

Wasserman, Melanie; Brenoe, Anne. 2022. "Math skills, perceptions of fit, and occupational choice." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010215. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10215-2.2

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Melanie Wasserman* , Anne Brenoe

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010215
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10215-2.2
First registered
Last updated
Status
Completed
Trial dates
2022-10-18 – 2024-01-01
Countries
Switzerland ()
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10215

Abstract

This study investigates whether the provision of gender-specific information on math ability and the suitability of various occupations affects beliefs regarding math ability/suitability, occupational search behavior, and occupational choice. We conduct a field experiment with Swiss students who are imminently choosing apprenticeships, a consequential decision for their eventual occupational outcomes. The experiment is conducted through an online survey in which students are randomized into two groups: (1) a treatment group that is shown a gender-specific information video that emphasizes that girls (boys) tend to be under- (over-) confident in math, which leads them to neglect certain more (less) math-intensive apprenticeships, and then advertises several occupations that are more (less) math-intensive for students to consider, and (2) a control group that is shown a video with information unrelated to specific occupational requirements/fit. We analyze whether the video affects (1) beliefs about own math ability (2) beliefs about the suitability of more (less) math-intensive occupations for themselves, (3) beliefs about the suitability of more (less) math-intensive occupations for other students with the same gender, (4) interest in more (less) math-intensive apprenticeships, and (5) applications for more (less) math-intensive apprenticeships.

Experimental design

We recruit study participants through schools, the largest online application site for Swiss apprenticeships, and career fairs.

The experiment is conducted through an online survey in which students are randomized into two groups (50% in each):
(1) a treatment group that is shown a gender-specific information video that emphasizes that girls (boys) tend to be under- (over-) confident in math, which leads them to neglect certain more (less) math-intensive apprenticeships, and then advertises several occupations that are more (less) math-intensive for students to consider
(2) a control group that is shown a video with information unrelated to specific occupational requirements/fit.

We stratify based on the respondent's gender (male/female), whether they have an apprenticeship contract already, and a proxy for having high or low math skills.

After the video, the survey asks girls (boys) their beliefs about their own math skills, perceptions of own fit, perceptions of others' fit, and willingness to sign up for a trial apprenticeship in a more (less) math-intensive occupations. We survey students two weeks later to assess persistence of perceptions of math skills and fit. At the end of the apprenticeship application cycle, we will merge the survey data with administrative data from the largest online platform for Swiss apprenticeships in order to observe submitted applications.

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization is done by a computer (javascript in Qualtrics). Upon completing the demographics portion of the survey, students are randomized into the treatment video or control video conditions.
Randomization unit
Individual
Clusters
3,000 students who do not yet have an apprenticeship contract
Observations
3,000 students who do not yet have an apprenticeship contract
Arms
1,500 treatment students, 1,500 control students
Primary outcomes
We estimate the effect of the treatment on: (1) girls' (boys') beliefs about own math ability (2) girls' (boys') beliefs about suitability of more (less) math-intensive occupations for themselves (3) girls' (boys') beliefs about the suitability of more (less) math-intensive occupations for other students with the same gender (4) interest of girls (boys) in more (less) math-intensive apprenticeships, as measured by demand for a more (less) math-intensive trial apprenticeship and demand for information about apprenticeships (5) applications for more (less) math-intensive apprenticeships, as measured by submitted applications from the largest online application platform for apprenticeships

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords