Does the framing of information on inequality in absolute or relative terms affect altruism?

How to cite

Tarp, Finn; Gisselquist, Rachel M.; Lichucha, Fernando; Dang, Thi Thu Hoai; Ferreira, Ines. 2022. "Does the framing of information on inequality in absolute or relative terms affect altruism?." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010212. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10212-3.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Finn Tarp* , Rachel M. Gisselquist , Fernando Lichucha , Thi Thu Hoai Dang , Ines Ferreira

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010212
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10212-3.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-11-14 – 2023-12-31
Countries
Private
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10212

Abstract

Other-regarding or social preferences – including altruism – are important in social interactions, cooperative behaviour and, more generally, in public life and politics. Previous literature has shown some evidence of the effects of information treatments on policy preferences, although the results are mixed. In light of the strand of literature showing that some individuals perceive inequality in absolute terms while others perceive inequality in relative terms (note that the most widely used measures are based on the latter), we examine whether the framing of information about inequality in absolute or relative terms affects altruistic behaviour.
We implement this economic experiment together with other games and a survey to collect background information on participants in both Mozambique and Vietnam.
More details are provided in the pre-analysis plan.

Experimental design

The game is a simple (non-incentivized) dictator game with low and high stakes that allows us to observe the differences in the amount participants would be willing to donate depending on the overall value that is at stake. We use it to derive a measure of altruism. An example of the text used in the low stakes questions is as follows, illustrating with the Mozambique case:
“Imagine that you were given 200 MZN that you could keep or donate (a share or the entire amount) to build a well-functioning hospital or health centre in the village I described. You see on your answer sheet that there are ten circles with a 20. They represent ten notes of 20, for a total of 200 MZN. In this case, how much would you choose to keep and how much would you choose to donate?”
Our experiment includes an information treatment, read to participants before they play the dictator games. All participants receive information about the difference in wealth of the poorest person and the richest person in one village. For example, in the case of Mozambique enumerators read the following: “I will now give you some information about a different village in Mozambique, for example, Alipe. This information is about a village in Mozambique. Many people live there.” To half of the participants in the session we frame this information in absolute terms (our absolute treatment) and show a diagram to highlight the absolute differences: “As you can see in this drawing, the richest person has 6 goats more than the poorest person.” To the other half of the participants we frame the information in relative terms (our relative treatment), again showing a diagram to highlight the relative differences: “As you can see in this drawing, the richest person has 4 times more goats than the poorest person.” This allows us to assess whether providing information about inequality in relative or absolute terms influences the participants’ answers in the dictator games.
Additionally, before receiving the information treatment and playing the dictator games, we ask participants a simple question to infer whether they think about inequality in absolute or relative terms. We then examine whether this indicator is correlated with the amounts chosen for donation in the dictator games.
The design of the study is based on between-subject comparison. In each country, we initially run a total of 40 sessions, 20 in rural settings and 20 in urban settings (see more details on the sampling in section 3) and we will add an additional round of 40 sessions, 20 in rural settings and 20 in urban settings, in the South of Vietnam. Each of the treatments is randomly allocated to half of the participants in each session.

Design details

Randomization method
The randomization is done within the experimental site. Half of the participants are randomly selected to go to a different room (based on a random count).
Randomization unit
The treatment is randomized at the individual level. Each of the treatments (absolute and relative) is randomly allocated to half of the participants in each session.
Clusters
1,040 individuals in Mozambique and 2,080 individuals in Vietnam (total of 3,120 individuals).
Observations
1,040 individuals in Mozambique and 2,080 individuals in Vietnam (total of 3,120 individuals).
Arms
In each data collection effort (Mozambique, North of Vietnam and South of Vietnam), 520 individuals receive the absolute treatment and 520 individuals receive the relative treatment.
Primary outcomes
Measures of altruism, which are the amounts indicated for donation in the dictator games with low and high stakes, respectively. We use this measure to address our main question ‘Does the framing of information on inequality in absolute or relative terms affect altruism?’ by testing whether there are significant differences between the groups who heard the treatment in absolute or in relative terms.

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords