Seeding Innovation Through Reality TV

How to cite

Sen, Ritwika; Udry, Christopher; Ferrara, Eliana La. 2022. "Seeding Innovation Through Reality TV." AEA RCT Registry. AEARCTR-0010198. https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10198-1.0

Download: BibTeX · RIS — for reference managers without a browser translator. Zotero and most others pick up this page's citation metadata directly.

Ritwika Sen* , Christopher Udry , Eliana La Ferrara

* Primary investigator

Registry ID
AEARCTR-0010198
DOI
https://doi.org/10.1257/rct.10198-1.0
First registered
Last updated
Status
On going
Trial dates
2022-02-14 – 2023-11-30
Countries
Private
JEL codes
O13, O14, D83
Registry record
http://www.socialscienceregistry.org/trials/10198

Abstract

The adoption of new agricultural technologies and improved farming practices are key elements of structural transformation and drivers of increased productivity in agriculture (Bustos, Caprettini and Ponticelli, 2016). Yet agricultural productivity remains far below its potential in many Sub-Saharan African countries. Our project investigates whether an innovative approach to provide technical information, consisting of agri-edutainment (educational entertainment) programs broadcasted on national television, can help to meet the informational needs of farmers. Two key distinguishing features of TV programs are that (i) they can easily convey information also to populations with relatively low literacy levels, and (ii) they are easy to distribute at scale at low marginal cost compared to traditional extension services. TV may also be a particularly useful medium to mitigate gender gaps in access and effectiveness of traditional extension services, to the extent that TV viewership is less gender-imbalanced than access to other services. Prior market research in Kenya indicates that a “makeover style” reality television show focused on farming as business helped to boost farmer incomes at a cost of only $0.50 per viewer. We leverage the planned rollout of this television program to Uganda (in 2022/23) to measure the causal impact and cost-effectiveness of the show in diffusing recommended techniques, and to better understand the process of information transmission and learning in agriculture.

Intervention

We evaluate the national rollout of a “makeover style” reality television program in Uganda that focuses on farming as a business. The television program helps to guide small scale farmers on a range of agricultural topics in an engaging yet informative way. Examples of core topics include soil and water management, planting, and pest and disease management. Each week, the film crew visits a different farming family and encourages them to identify their key goals and challenges in crop and livestock production. The show emphasizes why there is a problem and how best to deal with it. Local experts are brought to the farm to provide customized support to the family and clearly demonstrate simple yet affordable ways in which the household can implement the recommended adjustments on their farm.

The intervention is designed to generate exogenous variation in viewership of the farming TV program among comparable groups of farmers. We encourage a (randomly selected) group of rural farmers to watch the farming show, and another (randomly selected) group to watch a competing show that is broadcast at the same time. We will also shed light on farmers’ learning and adoption processes by studying the role of information provided to urban and rural contacts of control group farmers.

Experimental design

Our project covers 10 districts in the Central Region of Uganda reached by the Luganda language broadcast of the farming TV show. We identify a population of farming households with access to TV and randomly assign them to one of the following experimental arms: (1) Watchers; (2) “non-Watchers” and, (3) Information Only. We use a symmetric encouragement design to minimize the possibility that ‘non-Watchers’ are directly exposed to episodes of the farming TV program. That is, households in group (1) are encouraged to watch the farming TV program, while households in group (2) are encouraged to watch a competing show that is broadcast on national television at the same time. The households in group (3) receive weekly farming tips that convey the same information as the farming show but through a different medium: mobile phones (with no entertainment or visual demonstration of steps for farmers to emulate).

Design details

Randomization method
Randomization done in office by a computer using the software Stata.
Randomization unit
The unit of randomization is the household.
Clusters
N/A
Observations
3400 households
Arms
Targets/Estimates only: Watchers: 1000 Non-Watchers: 2000 Information Only: 400
Primary outcomes
The primary outcomes for this study will be measured under five key domains: 0. Take Up • The extent (0/1) and frequency of viewership of the targeted farming television program 1. Improved Knowledge of Agricultural Practices and Technologies We will use multiple choice questions (with unambiguously correct answers) to measure the knowledge of plot managers under this domain, including: • Theoretical knowledge of agricultural practices and technologies • Knowledge of specific practices and technologies recommended on the TV program 2. Changes in Production Practices and Agricultural Input Use. We will measure the following choices made by plot managers under this domain: • The adoption (0/1) of agricultural practices and technologies that are common in the study region • The adoption (0/1) of agricultural practices and technologies specifically recommended on the TV program • Expenses incurred (UGX) on agricultural inputs in the reference farming season • The choice of crops grown, and farm animals reared 3. Farm Productivity, Revenues and Sales to Market. • Production: Self-reported crop harvests in the reference agricultural season (volume) • Revenues: Value of crops harvested in the season, inclusive of production costs • Productivity: Crops harvested per unit of land area (volume and value) • Sales: Value of crops sold in unprocessed form (self-reported); average weekly income from the sales of processed crops and animal products; and crop sales as percentage of total output (commercialization). 4. The Diffusion of Information and Financial Resources. • Flows of information on financing for agricultural purposes from (and to) social networks in rural areas and towns/cities.
Secondary outcomes
1. Female Participation in Agricultural Decision-Making. This will be measured using the identity of decision makers on each plot cultivated by the household. We also measure changes in the decision rights of these plot managers, e.g., to build structures on the plot, rent it out to someone else, plant tree crops, or use it as a loan security. 2. Changes in attitudes related to women’s participation in business. • We will collect both explicit (self-reported) and implicit measures of attitudes toward women’s participation in business tasks. The implicit measures are based on implicit association tests that will be administered to respondents in our study sample. 3. Changes in income and business aspirations. • Subjective expectations about revenues from farming in the next agricultural season • Farming goals (e.g., crop choice, livestock and area cultivated) in 5 years’ time • Professional or business goals in 5 years’ time

Cited by

No citation data available for this registration yet.

Keywords